Monthly Archives: November 2010

Feminism

Women Against the Cuts protest tonight

It was seriously cold, it was seriously snowing, and Westminster was swarming with police, but there was a great turnout this evening for the first Women Against the Cuts event (about 150 or so at its peak I’d judge).

I’m afraid this rather blurry photo is all I have as evidence, because although it wasn’t on the schedule I did spend quite a bit of the evening on megaphone duty…

women against the cuts

There was a choir (a definitely higher class of protest), although my favourite chants were along the lines of “non-doms are shite”, and was really pleasing that so many of the protester took what I suspect was for many their first turn at a megaphone to deliver a personal message about their anger to the treasury.

For an organisation that only started around six weeks ago it was a magnificant effort – the next organising meeting is on Thursday and after that I’m sure much more will be planned.

Feminism

Women Against the Cuts Session at the Coalition of Resistance meeting

Went to an excellent session at the Coalition of Resistance national organising meeting yesterday run by Women Against the Cuts, which packed something like 80 women into a very small school classroom, with very small chairs! Among the groups whose members/reps were there were Feminist Fightback, the Older Feminist Network and the Radical Statistics Group. There were also two women who told us how they met at the first-ever Women’s Liberation march in London – the age range was about as wide as it could have been.

The session agreed to call for the addition of the following paragraph to the Conference Declaration:

“Acknowledging that women absorb many of the additional pressures from the cuts, the Coalition will strongly support efforts to defend services particularly used by women, and women-specific services. It will particular acknowledge the difficulties suffered by women from diverse communities, including women with disabilities, women from ethnic minorities, and pensioners.”

The conference committee, however, was faced with (depending on which account you believe, either 14 or 20 amendments), so the huge meeting (fairly enough) – some 1,300 strong – agreed to refer this to the Council elected at the meeting.

The session also called for the Council to be at least 50% female, a call that was acknowledged in the plenary session. The people who put themselves forward were 37% female – and I spoke to the organisers afterwards and strongly urged them to either reopen nominations for women or co-opt women to achieve gender balance – so we’ll see….

I had been asked to propose the motion, so here are some of the key details from the speech I never got to make for that:
* Independent House of Commons Library research has shown that the cuts will hit women twice as hard as men: two-thirds of the direct cuts will be forn by women, £11bn of £16bn.
* Over 65% of public service workers are women, and they make up 75% of local government workers, where the job cuts are likely to fall the hardest
* Benefits make up one-fifth of the average women’s income (one-tenth of the average man’s)
* 1m more women than men claim housing benefit – they make up 60% of the total
* 25% of women in their 50s have caring responsibilities

Miscellaneous

Gluten-free coconut and lemon biscuits

1/4 cup cornflour
1/4 cup sugar
3/4 cup rice flour
1/2 cup margarine
3/4 cup unsweetened coconut
Teaspoon of lemon juice

Mix dry ingredients, melt margarine in microwave, mix, make into balls and flatten wiith a fork

Bake for about 20 minutes in 180 degree oven.

Based on this recipe.

Miscellaneous Politics

How a life was defined by childhood poverty

My grandmother, Edna White, nee Boar, aged 90, is now in hospital in Australia, receiving palliative care after a massive stroke.

Hers was a life marked indelibly by the Great Depression. She never tired of telling the story of how at the age of 11 she got a scholarship to a grammar school, but because her parents couldn’t afford the tram fare, she had to go to a three-year high school, and then go out to work at 15.

She was very intelligent, and artistically talented, and ended up forging a financially comfortable life for herself, working as a legal secretary, which for a woman of her generation was a very good job.

But the psychological scars remained – she always felt that the world hadn’t given her her due, and hadn’t allowed her a fair go. That marked her life, and that of her family.

Today, with the massive welfare cuts in Britain, the hideous and growing inequality, how many more people are being so marked?

Update: Nan died peacefully in her sleep on November 21. Seeking information for her death certificate, I’ve had cause to delve into the family history and learnt that her mother was Florence (nee) Grose, her father’s William R. C. Boor. They were married in Paddington (Australia) in 1919. (Nan was born on the 13th April, 1921, and married in 1946.) Two generations much marked also by war.

Books Feminism

Reclaiming the F Word – a survey across, but not judgement of, contemporary feminism

First published on Blogcritics

I read Reclaiming the F Word, the much-awaited book by the former editor of the website The F-Word, some months ago when it first came out, indeed even went to the launch in a West End club, but hadn’t found time to write up a review (not enough long train trips recently – at least not ones where I’ve been fit to do any more than sleep).

It wasn’t what I expected – I’d been predicting something more analytical, which tried to present a path forward for feminism and a vision of the future. That’s definitely not what it is.

Rather it’s a snapshot of today – based heavily on a survey of 1,265 feminists, self-described (I was one of them). There are descriptions of types of feminism of today, and surveys of views, but very little in the way of judgements of worth or value.

But provided you take the book for what it is, it’s a valuable work – certainly highly useful as an introduction to modern feminism, and as a guide for those thinking about becoming involved in feminism work but not quite sure where to start. (And with the detailed result presented in an appendix, no doubt invalulable to future historians, and as a source for present-day sociologists.)

It’s also heavy of pointers to further reading, namechecking many of the feminist books and writers of the past decade or so. There’s also plenty of basic facts and figures on women’s status and position, if sometimes they feel a little random,

Adding to the “introduction to feminism” feel,each chapter finishes with a list of possible actions the reader might take, ranged across levels of radicalism and effort.

The focus is slanted towards the UK and the West, but there’s enough discussion of the critical problems of women in the developing world to ensure that any reader new to feminism at least gets a sketch of the international dimension.

But if you’ve been around for a long time, as I have, you won’t find much to surprise you.

It was in the appendix that I found, for me, the most valuable data. The survey question that asked feminists to rank their concerns by importance put inequality in work/home/education top, with well over 600 respondents, and “violence against women” at about 600. “The body”, primarily abortion and reproductive rights was third.

All of these were well above “popular culture” including responses relating to objectification/sexualisation, the issue that I think is consuming far too much time and energy in current feminist efforts.

While I’d class myself, when pushed, as a radical feminist, rather than as a Marxist/socialist one, I think these campaign in attacking the end result of hyper-capitalism are failing to get anywhere near our real problems, which lie in our extreme consumerist culture, for which the use of sex as a commodity to sell pretty well anything at all is merely a logical outcome.
read more »

Environmental politics Politics

Notes from the Scottish Green Party conference

I was delighted to be an observer last weekend for the England and Wales Party at the Scottish conference. Aside from drinking some (well quite a bit actually) of homemade damson gin, I did get to lots of sessions, and eventually get the hang of the rather complicated but certainly efficient system for voting in plenary sessions.

This is a collection of notes and highlights..

Robyn Harper, who will be stepping down next May after 12 years as an MSP, recalled how he came to join the party. A former student had given him a joining form which he put in his coat pocket, where it stayed until the day the Rainbow Warrior was bombed. That spurred him into joining what was then the Ecology Party.

The lesson from this: always carry and hand out joining leaflets…

He was highly positive about next year’s Scottish Parliamentary elections, with the nice line “the best way to predict the future is to invent it”.

“We should be able to get at least 1% off each of then Tories, Lib Dems and Nationalists.” If the Greens did that, they’d be in the running for 9 seats andd quite possibly be in a position to shape or be part of the next government. “If the chance comes for Green ministers we need to be ready.”

The EIS* fringe session
Jacqui Helburn, EIS director, said Scots had to defend against some of the worst ideological excesses of the Condems “down south,” as represented by Academy and “free” schools creeping into Scotland. The comprehensive system had to be defended.

The problems had already started, she said. The SNP had promised to maintain 52,000 teachers and keep class sizes down but already 3,500 had lost their jobs and of teachers who had completed their induction year this year, only 10% now had permanent jobs.

The EIS is running a big campaign “Why Must Our Children Pay?”

MSP Robyn Harper, a former teacher, highlighted the importance of music, drama, PE and movement classes. These were highlighted in the “Curriculum for Excellence”, which was proving very popular in primary schools, he said, although secondaries were finding it more difficult.

Jacqui said that it was music and singing lessons at school that had given her the confidence to be where she is now. Robyn said: “I have no problem with defending to the death music lessons, in terms of the confidence, teamworking, empathy and other skills they help develop.” In times of cutbacks they were always the first to suffer, “but they are at the centre of the Curriculum for Excellence”.

He added that it was not just teaching that was critical in terms of funding. “We have 50 areas of multiple deprivation. They need social work inputs.”

(* Interesting organisation – they represent both primary and secondary teachers and have achieved an integrated payscale for them, I found through chatting on their stall.)

Going Carbon Neutral Stirling
Rachel Nunn has run a highly regarded project in Stirling charged with “getting the mass audience that wwas unengaged in sustainability and carbon reduction” to get involved.

She said its aim was to create a new social norm so that even after the project ended behaviour change continued.

It’s clearly regarded as a roaring success and has rigorous procedures, with monthly evaluations and redrawing of the project in response. It now has 30% of people involved in carbon reduction with a budget of £1.5m, nine staff over four years.

There’s a lot of selling involved – staff “cold call” organisations to ask them to get involved – 65% say ‘yes’ and that involves contact controlled by the initial organisation – “it might be two minute with a football club befor they run out on the pitch to half an hour with the knitting group.”

Ninety-five per cent of groups agree to become involved, “People know it is the right thing to do, and we’re helped by our high visibility in Stirling.”

But it was there that the story got a bit less positive. “Of the 241 groups that said ‘yes’ 126 have done any meaningful activity.”

Additionally, it had been hoped that reaching families through children in schools would be effective, but a recent evaluation found that less than 2% of parents knew about the carbon cutter plans. “We try to reach them through emails, newsletters, homework — all the usuall channels — but it seems they don’t pay attention.”

Her conclusion was that something of an impasse has been reached: “People are bored with the easy stuff and can’t quite be bothered to tackle the hard stuff.”

She said that often people asked if the programme could be replicate by voluntary effort. She clearly thought not – “It is asking too much of volunteers. You need the right set of skills – often selling skills more usually found in the commercial sector – and the time to spend on speaking to people.”