Author Archives: Natalie Bennett

Notes from Waves Across the South: A New History of Revolution and Empire

p. 12 “In 1793, two kidnapped Maori were brough to Norfolk Island off the coast of Australia, in order to teach convicts how to work the flax that grew on many of the island’s coastal cliffs. These two kidnapped men are now commonly called Tuki and Huru. They came to Norfolk Island on the Shah Hormuzear, which was crewed by lascars, and which had arrived at Port Jackson (now Sydney) from Calcutta. On their way to Norfolk Island they travelled in the company of 2,200 gallons of wine and spirits, six Bengal ewes and two rams. They were the first Maori to live in a European community, and the kidnapped Tuki, a priest’s son, and Huru, a young chief, became close to the commandant of the convict settlement, Philip Gidley King. King was unable to discern much about flax-workinf from the pair, given that it was women who worked the flax in their communities. Yet he got Tuki to draw a map.

One commentator noted the extent of Tuki’s interests …”not only very inquisitive respecting England & C. (the situation of which, as well as that of New Zealand, Norfolk Island and Port Jackson) he well knew how to find by means of a coloured general chart)… he was also “very communicative respecting his own country… Perceiving he was not thoroughly understood, he delineated a sketch of New Zealand with chalk on the floor. Tuki’s map of his “country” is extraordinary not only because it is thought to be the oldest map drawn by a Maori.. It shows …Mauis’s Fire, the North Ireland; and .. Greenstone Water, the South Island. … a double-dotted line across the North Island shows the road taken by the spirits of the dead … and the place for leaping off into the underworld. .. Within this map, and in the conversations that happened around its making, Tuki attended to population, harbours, the concentration of fighting men and the availability of water… On their return to New Zealand, Tuki and Huru became important intermediaries between Maori and the British.”

p. 16 Peter “Dillon was an erratic maritime adventurer and private trader with aspirations of greatness, an Irisman born in French Martinique in 1788. If he is to be believed, he had served in the Royal Navy at the Battle of Trafalgar in 1805. He then sailed for the Pacific. He was known to foster close relationships with South Pacific islanders, an attachment which began when he was resident in Fiji 1809-09, when he made “considerable progress in learning their language”… From 1908, he set himself up in Sydney, using it as a base for his private trade across the Pacific. He moved to Calcutta in 1816 and traded between Bengal and the Pacific. By this time, he had married. Mary Cillon accompanied him on his voyages from Calcutta. .. His voyage of 1825-6 falls squarely in the middle of the age of revolutions and Dillon’s career is a telling gauge of changing gimes. For the British Empire followed in the wake of people who may be placed next to Dillon, namely private traders, sailors, castaways, missionaries and so-called pirates. The new empire sought to reform their activities with more systematic colonisation, “free trade” and liberal government. In keeping with this shift to formal empire, Dillon spent the later phase of his life in Europe. He now combined a new set of interests, presenting plans for the settlement of the Pacific to the governments of France and Belgium and publishing a proposal for the colonisatio of New Zealand by the British. In the 1840s, he was an active member of a characteristic association of reform in mid-19th-century Britain, the Aborigines Protection Society, whihc was tied up with the humanitarian heritage of anti-slavery. He also set out a plan for sending Catholic missionaries to the Pacific. He died in Paris in 1847.”

p. 17 voyage of St Patrick of 1825-6 “around 20 British sailors who had joined the crew had served in Chile’s war of independence against Spain, under the command of Thomas Cochrane, a British naval officer who played a pivotal role in the rebel navies of Chile, Peru and Brazil in the 1820s… 11 Pacific islanders .. also had on board a Chinese cook and a Bengali steward… A disturbing story told by George Bayly, the third mate… involves Dillon’s wife Mary. “His wife lived on board and he very frequently have her a thrashing…”.. Bayly said of himself “never was a captive bird more pleased to get its liberty than I was.”.. these shipboard relationships were unstable, unpredictable and violent and based on gender, status and race”.

p. 91 The language of the American and French revolutions, and the example of the Batavian Republic, was used by the trekboer in support of a conservative culture of settlement. This culture of settlement generated a local age of revolutions. It included the boers’ commitment to the harsh discipline of slaves and aggressive conflict with indigenous peoples. Such practices set a context for the expansion of the counter-revolutionary British Empire.”

p. 92 “Among enslaved people, the revolutionary rhetoric of these decades drawn from overseas was fundamentally reworked to suit local agendas. The year 1808 saw a significant slave rebellion in Cape Town. It began when two Irishmen told the 30-year-old Louis, the keeper of a wine shop, who was an enslaved person owned by the “separated wife of Willem Kirsten” that in Ireland, England, Scotland and America “there were no Salves, but all free people, that all people ought to be set free”… a group of enslaved people proceeded to take control of 34 farms in Zwartland, Koeberg and Tygerberg, districts where grapes and grain were grown. After the revolt’s suppression, about 300 prisoners were take. Sixteen of them were sentenced to death, 244 were returned to their masters… The Irishmen were appregended while attempting to escape to sea from Saldanha Bay.”

p. 130 “The glorification of Wahhabi revolt, and the interpretation of it as revolutionary, emerged partly from the period’s colonial writings. Indeed, in the early 19th century and in the context of the Napoleonic era, the Wahhabis could be case as akin to the people of the Swiss cantons or the Dutch United Provinces set “against crusading Catholic potentates”. In this rendition they could be glossed positively for how they stoof up to Ottoman tyrannt. If this was a period when ‘revolution’ was an unstable term of reference, especially in the British perception of the concept, the Wahhabies were revolutionary. In addition, European commentators sought to make sense of the Wahhabis through analogy to the Christian past. These were the inspired “Protestant” Muslims.”

p. 160 “the Navigation Laws, according to which British ships arriving and departing from London had to have predominately British crews, this despite the heavy reliance on Indian lascars. In practice this meant that lascars often took up work on vessels on the way to London … but such lascars found themselves stranded without work on getting to London, at times having to become passengers on the return journey. There was also an increasing feeling of rivalry, resentment and conflict on the part of lascars directed towards British officers and crew members on shops, connected to differences in pay and their exploittative use… attempts at reform generated further bureaucract rather than improvement in conditions… The so called ‘Lascar Act’ after the end of the Napoleonic Wars further precluded the legal use of Indian seamen on British vessels. These wider conditions framed the types of insurrections which occured amon lascars in the circuit of country trade between Bombay and the Gulf.”

p. 167 Cora Gooseberry … was an Eora woman.. a term for over 30 clans of Aboriginal people who resided in the Sydney region. She was the widow of Bungaree, who is often said to be the first person called an Australian in print… Both Cora’s remaining breastplates are engraved with fish and this is probably not an accident. It is now know that coastal Eora Aboriginal women played an important role fishing with hooks and lines from their nowie or canoes… with children in tow, while men usually fished with spears from the shore.”

Pages: 1 2

Podcast: Orban Regime, a PLD?

I’m by no means an expert on Hungary, never even been there, but this New Books Network interview with András Körösényi, one of the authors of The Orbán Regime: Plebiscitary Leader Democracy in the Making, was fascinating. (And also introduced me to an aspect of Weber with which I was previously unfamiliar.)

And I’m going to have to think about this a bit more, but as a concept would seem to have considerable explanatory power for the Boris Johnson regime too – as I see it close up, with institutions and (where possible) the law, being moulded to the convenience of those in charge (Brexit deal announced on December 24 and debated in one day by parliament on December 30 anyone?), and conventions in policy-making being tossed out the window (Henry VIII powers being the tool of choice).

Podcast: Electoral Capitalism in New York’s Gilded Age

As I first started listening to Jeff Broxmeyer’s account of “spoils democracy”, on the New Books Network I thought about the Thailand that I knew in the 1990s, very much a patronage-based society, but where often people needed the modest spoils they got from that to survive.

But it was impossible also to not think of how much of a circle we’ve come in – just the sums have got much larger and the distribution much narrower – whether it is Trump family businesses or the UK’s crony-based distribution of Covid-19 (so extreme it attracted the attention of the New York Times).

New Books Network: A Fourth-Century Daoist Family

Fascinating in detail, and quite spectacular in its account of how examination of a single footnote, and detective work around it, led to a significant rethinking of the relationship between Daoism and Buddhism.

“The Declarations of the Perfected collects fragmentary texts—poems, information on the realm of the dead, instructions for practice—revealed to Yang Xi (330—ca. 386) by celestial beings. These texts were assembled and annotated by Tao Hongjing (456–536).”

Notes from The Swallow, A Biography by Stephen Moss

p. 26 Swallows breed across virtually the whole of Europe and Asia, from Ireland in the West, almost as far as the Bering Strait in the east, and south to the southernmost point of China, Hainan ISland – less than 20 degrees north of the equator… western populations mostly migrate to sub-Saharan Africa, while more eastern breeders head down to the Indian sub-continent, south-east Asia and even northern Australia.”

P. 29 So how different are swallows, martins and swifts from one another? By far the easiest to identify is the swift, which is about as closely related to swallows and martins as owls are to kestrels – that is, not at all. Their superficially similar appearance is via the process of convergent evolution, because both swifts and swallows hunt flying insects. Swifts are not passerines at all, but in a completely different order, the Apodiformes. This also includes the hummingbirds, with which they share many physical characteristics and habits. Swifts only come to land when they visit their nests, and even then they struggle… scientific name, Apus apus, means ‘no foot, no foot”. … they are almost entirely sooty-brown (appearing black in most lights) and have long, narrow, curved wings shaped like a scythe; not at all like the triangular wings of the swallows and martins. And while swallos and martins twitter, swifts scream, often rushing across the firmament like jet fighters”.

p. 31 “house martins are easy to identify. They are blue-black above, white below, and with a predominately white rump above a dark, short and slightly forked tail (whereas the swallow’s upperparts are completely blue-black. Overall, as Bill Oddie has pointed out, their colour and patterns bear a strikiung resemblence to a rather larger predator, the killer whale. House martens also nest on the outside of buildings, rather than inside as most barn swallows do.”

p. 32 “swallow is one of just 16 words for birds that occur in Anglo-Saxon literature. In one of the earliest collections of Old English writings, the Epinal-Erfurt Glossary (two manuscrupts compiled for Aldhelm, the Abbot of Malmesbury around the year AD 700) it appears alongside the Latin word Hirundo as “swaluuae”.

p. 72 Like almost all songvirds, the female lays a single egg each day – usually early in the morning – and does not start to incubate until the whole clucth is complete, thus ensuring the chicks will all hatch out at roughly the same time. She incubates the egg for between 13 and 16 days, with no help at all from her mate (in Britain and Europe at least) … But once the chicks hatch – naked, blind and helpless, and each weighing less than 2 grams – the male refeems himself by taking a full part in their feeding. Indeed, of all the world’s 5,000 or more songbirds, male swallows and martins make the greatest contribution to caring for the young.”

p. 73 “bring a bolus (concentrated ball) of a hundred or more insects bac to the nest, sometimes at a rate of one visit every minute”.

New Books Network: White Freedom by Tyler Stovall

I’ve recently become a devotee of the New Books Network podcasts.

Cooking, gardening, house tidying, even exercise, has suddenly become much less boring – and I’m getting through the equivalent of eight or so academic seminars a week.

Being me the focus is on eclectic. I’ve found very few interviews I haven’t considered intellectually exciting (the selection is clearly on most channels really rigous) – although I have downloaded a few that went too deep outside my areas of knowledge of interest to hold me. The only problem is of course I want to read about half of the books, which would only be achievable if I did nothing else.

But been thinking about keeping a record so I can find them again and recommending what I think are the good ones to others. I’ve long done that with Philobiblon with books, so it seemed like a logical addition.

Notes of what is said are not necessarily agreement – I may be noting interesting thoughts rather than things I 100% agree with.

A good place to start is White Freedom, belonging to what might be considered the “criticism of the Enlightenment” genre.

“Stovall explores how French and American thinkers defined freedom in racial terms and conceived of liberty as an aspect and privilege of whiteness. He discusses how the Statue of Liberty—a gift from France to the United States and perhaps the most famous symbol of freedom on Earth—promised both freedom and whiteness to European immigrants. … challenges the notion that racism is somehow a paradox or contradiction within the democratic tradition, demonstrating how white identity is intrinsic to Western ideas about liberty.”