Category Archives: Media

Media

Plagiarism is the highest form of flattery

… and beside you can’t plagiarise an idea. Boing Boing reports on a mashup that puts together just the headline of New York Times stories and the final paragraph. The results can be surprisingly illuminating. So I thought I’d try it with the Guardian website – this is a random selection of stories (every second one, starting from the top about five minutes ago):

Beslan terrorist leader killed, reports say
“I admit, I’m a bad guy, a bandit, a terrorist … but what would you call [the Russians]?” he said in an interview with ABC News last year. “If they are the keepers of constitutional order, if they are anti-terrorists, then I spit on all these agreements and nice words.”

Anger at decision not to review paedophile’s sentence
Lord Goldsmith has referred almost 700 cases for review of undue leniency since he took over the top law officer’s job in 2001. In 521 cases, the court agreed, and 414 offenders had their sentences increased.

Police question ex-soldier over family killings
Huma Ahmed, who lives a few doors away from the Purcell family, was in tears as she laid flowers. She said: “They were a really nice family and I am really shocked that something like this could happen. It is really sad and we can’t believe this has happened. We used to see them in the street all the time and would always say hello to each other.”

Kidnapped Israeli soldier is alive, Hamas says
Around 20,000 people staged an anti-Israel demonstration in Turkey’s biggest city, Istanbul, prior to the signing of an agreement between Turkish and Palestinian politicians yesterday. The deal guarantees $1m of business support and 10,000 tonnes of flour as food aid to the Palestinian territories.

Well, it works remarkably well with news stories. (Features might be a bit more puzzling.) It seems it really is time to declare the inverted pyramid dead.

Media Politics

A victim strikes out

You’ll remember the shocking close-up pictures in all the tabloids, and broadsheets, of a schoolgirl whose face had been slashed with a pencil-sharpener, a network of horribly painful-looking stitches. Much ink was expended on a similar web of “what is the world coming to” outrage. But it turns out, the whole story was rather more complicated, and it sounds like the jury made a very humane decision in opting to throw out the more serious charge levelled at the 12-year-old:

During the three-day trial, jurors heard that Shanni [the victim] assaulted the girl the day before the classroom attack, punching her and banging her head against a wall as more than 100 pupils looked on. Nobody came to the girl’s aid.
The jury was told that the defendant was the only Somali girl in her year and had few friends. She lived in Somalia for the first 10 years of her life, without any formal education, and was orphaned when she was young.
Her isolation at school led to bullying – some of it racially motivated – at the hands of her peers. Teachers were aware of this problem and they also knew the girl had learning difficulties.

History Media

A press retrospective

Over on Your London My London I’ve just reviewed Front Page: Celebrating 100 Years of the British Newspaper. But is it an early obituary, one pulled from the morgue just a little too soon?

Although of course the British Library will be dealing with the corpse for a long time. The Colindale repository is apparently full, the storage conditions inadequate, and a high percentage of the collection at risk, newsprint being, by its nature, a librarian’s nightmare.

Feminism Media

A typical Mail character assassination

The “Aids avenger”, a woman jailed for knowing infecting a man with HIV, has allowed the Mail on Sunday to go positively over the top. She – once a respectable middle-class girl has, on its account, shock horror – slept with black men and had a child with one of them, she went out dancing, she didn’t take the respectable secretary’s job her parents want her to take but instead went to work for an advertising agency. And then she turned against men – gosh, one of the male senior staff on the Mail could have accidentally ended sleeping with the woman, or one like her. And – serve her right – she ended up living in a council flat.

Oddly enough, the Independent has a story on the same court case, although were it not for the same name you wouldn’t know it. On its account:

Ms Porter’s friends say that far from luring dozens of men into a fatal honeytrap, she had just two relationships after discovering she was HIV-positive. Her only crime was an inability to admit to herself she had the virus. “She felt it was shameful and dirty,” a friend said.

Another friend added: “She dotes on her little boy and he dotes on her. The idea that she’s out clubbing every weekend picking up men is just wrong. She has a small son to look after. She isn’t the type to have one-night stands … She just pushed the HIV to the back of her mind – so far back that it was hardly there for her. She couldn’t even say ‘HIV’.

Some of that is a bit disingenuous – I wouldn’t entirely take it on trust either, but I know which I think is closer to the truth.

Now there does have to be personal responsibility, and while it sounds like counselling and support services did fail her, and quite possibly mental health services as well, she still has to take some responsibility for her actions, and behave appropriately in future. (So, of course, should have the men – had they practiced safe sex there wouldn’t be a problem.)

But will jailing her for what will probably end up being about a year, and separating her from her child (a totally innocent victim) produce that result?

Media

So?!

Having just read my way through four British newspapers, Guardian, Times, Independent, Telegraph, I was unsurprised to find a virtually identical headline in all of them – “Gay/Homosexual couple jailed for abusing foster children”.

A small prize (not a Cadbury’s chocolate) to the first reader who can find a headline reading “Hetereosexual couple guilty of…”.

Media

RIP: The tabloid pun is dead

… or at least on the way out.

I’ve always thought that punning headlines are written by journalists for journalists, a form of schoolboy showing off. The occasional real good one might produce a wry smile in me, but usually my response is a groan, since most of them are neither original nor interesting.

And I suspect most readers don’t notice or are at best mildly irritated by them – the way you are annoyed by the school clown showing off by taunting a new teacher when you’d rather listen to what the teacher has to say.

But as Peter Preston says in The Guardian today, Google et al are going to kill such headlines stone dead. No search algorithm, no matter how tricky, is going to understand a pun.

But some things in the media are slower to change. The Guardian profiles Quentin Letts — “Haileybury. Trinity College, Dublin and Jesus College, Cambridge” — the Daily Mail’s parliamentary sketch-writer, theatre critic and author of the paper’s new satirical column, Clement Crabbe”. The interview is conducted in, of course, his London club, where he “lives during the parliamentary season”. His wife stays back in Herefordshire.

He laughs. “I’ve got three children and a wife who has the opposite of a hosepipe ban when it comes to spraying money around. So I’ve got to make hay while the sun shines.”