Category Archives: History

Books History Women's history

Notes From The Horde: How the Mongols Changed the World

p. 5 “”In some senses, manufactured objects were luxuries for the nomads, yet the nomads were not frivolous. Long-distance exchange and circulation of manufacturer goods were not essential to subsistence, yet they were the backbone of the social order. Mongol economies relied on the circulation of these goods, in particular their redustribution from the khan to the elites to the commoners, a system that sumulaneously reinforced social rank, created bonds of dependence, and gave even the least in society a reason to feel invested in the success of the regime. Steppenomads further understood circulation as a spiritual necessity. Sharing wealth mollified the spirits of the dead, the sky and the earth.”

p. 10 “Horder when it was applied to the people of Jochi, was an old word for a new regime…To the Mongols themselves, horde had a wide and complex meaning. A horde was an army, a site of power, a people under a ruler, a huge camp. These meanings did not exclude one another: in concert, they captured the sense that the regime was coextensive with its mobile people. A horde did not have to be in one place in order to govern itself or sedentary subjects: hordes migrated, dispersed and gathered anew, all while exercising control.”

p. 12 The Horde was socially diverse and multiethnic, but its leadership came from a core of dominant steppe clans, most of them Mongol subgroups… The heads of these groups bore the title of beg. As the Horde became increasingly oligarchic in the late 13th century, power fevolved from the khan to the begs… The begs acknowledged the khan’s primacy because he was a descendent of Chingiss Khan’s eldest son Jochi. Bu that status did not make the khan all-powerful. To be elecated on the felt rug – the procedure of enthronement – an aspirant had to associate himself with powerful begs. Similarly, to rule effectively, a khan needed the begs on his side. They supported him and, if he failed, deposed him. This was especially the case after the 1350s, during and following a period known as the bulqaq – anarchy.”

p. 13 If the Horde were projected on today’s maps, it would stretch across a region occupied by Ukraine, Bulgaria, Moldavia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Ukbekistan, Turkmenistan and Russia, including Tatarstan and Crimea. … Where nationalisms solidified in opposition to Mogol rule, historians have told one kind of story: where nationalisms presume continuity with the Mongol past, historians have told another kind of story.”

o, 26 In summer 1219 Mongol armies were gathering in the Altai Mountains, near the source of the Irtysh River. Chingiss Khan … sent for Master Qui Chuji, the most respected Taoist leader in northern China. The 71-year-old Qui Chuji was highly influential, and his flock growing as people looked to his guidance amid war and famine. Until this point, Qui Chuji had refused to work with the Mongols, just as he had refused to work with the Chinese emperors. For Chingiss, Taoist support would be priceless, helping the Mongols pacify northern China while they were busy conquoring Central Asia. But there was another reason … the khan was no in his late fifties, while the typical warrior barely reached his forties. Chinggis could no longer take each year for granted, and he hoped to learn from Qiu Chuji the secret of longevity… At their first meeting, the conqueror asked the monk “Have you a medicine of immortality?” Qui Chuji replied “There are means for preserving life, but not medicine for immortality. Satisfied with Qui Chuji’s honesty, Chingiss have him the appeallation shinsen, the immortal, and ordered Qui Chuji’s tents be pitched just each of his own… The Taoist master spent more than a year in Chingiiss Khan’s camp and in Samarkand, which the Mongols had taken in 1220. In conversations, Qui Chuji explained the doctrine of the Tao and addvised Chingiss Khan to avoid cruelty and sensulaity and warned him not to go hunting anymore… helped Chingiss secure the surrender of the northern Chinese and their acceptance of the Mongol order. An able administrator, Qui Chuji knew the Mongols would provide better governance of the region.. In 1224, on his way back to northern China, the monk stopped in Zhongdu, where he ordered his new headquarters built. That same year, he sent his followers throughtout the region to take control of temples and summon the Buddhist and Taoist clergy to submit to the Mongol Empire.”

p. 36 The Birth of the Mogol Ulus In spring 1206, the Year of the Tiger, an assembly of the Felt-Walled Tents, known as a quriltai, gathered near the sources of the Onion River. As they collected for the meeting, Temuhin’s standard was hoisted. The standard was a pole with the tails of nine white-haired horses at the top, symbolising the peace and unity of the Felt-Walled Tents under Mongol rule … According to Rashid l-Din, a Persian historian of the Mogols writing in the early 14th century, the creator of Temuijin’s enthronement ritual might have been Teb Tengri, an influential shaman who also suggested Temuijin’s new title… Chingiss Khan, a term meaning “mighty” or possibly “universal”… This was a clear break from recent political practices.”

p. 84 During the Russian campaign (1235-1242), the Mongols gained control of some 20 cities. They did not destroy all these cities. Rostov, for example, was spared after its inhabitants accepted peace terms. Kiev, on the other hand, rejected an identical offer and was sacked.. The Mongols were experts in siege warfare and had accumulated even more experience throughout their recent operations against the Jin… The Russians were helpless when faced with seige engines they had never seen before. Adapting Chinese technology, the Mongols built catapults 26 feet high and weighing five tons. Such a machine could throw a stone heavier than 132 pounds up to 164 yeards. For a commander like Subotei, who had conquerored more than 30 stone and brick fortresses in China, Central Asia and Iran, the wooden and earthern walls of Russian cities presented no real challenge. What was challenging for the Mongols was the terrain. Muddy and swampy grounds limited their operation to the coldest months and restricted their range of activity. They could move quickly on frozen soil and rivers, but with the snow already melting in March, their armoured troops and heavy seige engines got stuck in the mire.”

p. p. 102 In 1237 Ogodei went a step further and established a preferential marriage system between the male and female descendents of Chingiss Khan and the Qonggirad. Imperial chief wives were thus sipposed to be of Quonggirad origin, although Ogodei’s order was not rigorously followed. The decision probably reflected the fact that Borte, Chinggis Khan’s first wife, was the daughter of Dei Sechen, chief of the Qonggirad. A khan had many khatun because marriage was a political partnership but only few of the women were chief wives, with their own extended households. Secondary wives and concubines often stayed with the chief wives who controlled them. The chief wife could be highly influential: she might have her own court of secretaries, treasurers and traders and sit at the quiriltai.

p. 109 The fattening of horses and camels during periods of calving and milking was crucial to the pastoral economy. During these months, usually from May to September, the herds needed to rest. When the mares were milking, they did not march with the khan’s horde. The Mongols used this five-month long season not only to relax – these were essentially peaceful stretches – but also to organise extensive political meetings and take governing decisions. It was no accident that the Mongols planned enthronements and great quirltai during the drinking festival they held in the summer.

p. 111 The Mongols did not consider humanity superior to nature, and humans were not the masters of the environment. Mongols saw animals, plants, terrain, and insects as lifeforms to be feared and respected. They believed in the “land masters”, the intangible entities of the land, defined by the anthropologist Gregory Delaplace as “localised at a certain place, commanding such diverse phenomena as weather, luck for hunting, and encironmental conditions in general. And the Mongols handled the earth and wildlife with great caution, as these entities could be vengeful and hostile. Mongols worshiped nature and cared for it deeply.”

p. 112 Preparing kumis required experience, skill and patience, for it entailed stirring or chaurning raw mare’s milk for hours. It was also a symbolically loaded task that only men were able to perform. A fizzy drink. kumis typically had an ethyl alcohol content of between 1 and 2.5%, but the level could be raised if the milk fermented longer. … more than a shared tradition. It was also a vital part of the Mongol diet. Shamans knew kumis was an unparalleled energy booster and used it in various rituals… researchers have shown that kumis from animals milked around June, exactly when the drinking festival was in full flow – yields especially high levels of vitamin E, niacin and dehydroascorbic acid, a form of vitamin C… Fresh kumis strengthens the immune system and treats and prevents typhoid, dysentry, and other diseases that were common … also has antibiotic properties and is still used against bacterial infections. The Mongols recognised that kumis was useful in treating kidney stones, which was likely a prevalent ailment. As avid meat eaters, the Mongols probably had elevated levels of uric acid, which leads to painful afflictions such as kidney stones and gout.”

p.118 Around 1250 Batu sponsored the construction of permanent structures at a location the Mongols recorded on their coins as Sarai, meaning palace or city … Not much is known… It is a common mistake to compare Sarai to a classical imperial city, for the khan would neither live within four walls nor have his mausoleum constructed there. He also did not try to impress his people with buildings. Sarai probably served a function similar to that of Qaraqorum, “the sitting city” Ogodei had founded two decades earlier … an enclosed, brick-walled town with two districts, one for Muslim merchants and one for Chinese craftsmen. Next to the great khan’s palace there were a number of palaces for court secretaries, 12 Buddhist temples, two mosques and a church… a meeting point for outsiders. Sarai hosted traders, travelers, secretaries, artisans and religious men, who found there the comforts of sedentary life…. Mongols themselves considered sedentary residences less comfortable than their tents, which were warmer, softer and more intimate… As a centre of trade, religion and craft, Sarai helped to advance the political and economic goals of the Horde and, as it grew, elevated the Khan’s prestige. What Sarai was not was an administrative center. Mongols ruled on horseback.”

p. 128 Since at least the 7th century, Turks, Kiran, Uighurs and other Central Asian rulers had implemented messaging systems. The Mongols merged these regional networks and fit them to their own ambitions. By the mid-13th century, the yam was fully operational. There were hundreds of yam stations, small camps run by Mongols and locals, where official travellers and emissaries could obtain food and fresh mounts. The cost of maintaining the stations fell on the local people, who were required to provide horses, water, food and clothing and to accomodate official travellers foreign emissaries and their escorts. The yamchi, postmen, who staffed the stations, did not give away horses but rather exchanged them for horses that the travelers had received from a previous station. Mongols were selective about horses. They distinguished between pack, post and war horses and between those suited to long distances and sprinters useful for urgent missions across short distances. The army controlled the whole yam system.

In the Qichaq steppe, yam stations were located roughly a half-day’s distance from each other … All the yam horses belonged to the empire; the yam operated like a state-run horse rental company, that covered the whole Mongol territory… The tergen yam, comprising carts pilled by oxen, camels and strong horses, moved heavy loads and only covered portions of territoies. The morin yam, the regular postal route, was limited to riders on horseback, and ran trough th whole empire. And via the narin yam, a secret communication system, a messenger could travel more than 120 miles in a day … The yam made the steppe smaller.

p. 180 Life in the hordes was unusually safe and secure, surprising European visitors. The Jochids tried to ensure similar order in the Russian principalities, so that the people could achieve economic output and population growht that would fuel the khan’s regime. To this end, the Mongols regulated Russian subjects much as they did their own, banning Russians from carrying weapons and riding war horses, while depitizing local rulers to provide security… To confirm the positions of local rulers, the Mongols granted them yarliks – written diplomas, which had long been used across the empire to make formal announcements.

p. 186 the Jochis had to rely on middlement on the coasts, who could connect them to the world beyond Caffa [modern Crimea] was a strategically privleged location … Through the Genoese, the Mongols could control the nearby strait of Kerch, which connects the Black and Azov seas. Whoever controlled the strait controlled Black Sea access to the Horde… the alliance with the Byzantines had strengthened the Jochld’s control over Black Sea access and allowed its people to exit and enter through the Bosporus and Dardanelles, the alliance with the Mamluks gave the Jochids access to the Nile and the Red Sea.”

p. 187 “Another key to Jochid commerce under Mongke-Temur;s reign was southeastern Moldavia… they could watch the end points of the Dniester and Danube rivers, critical trade routes that connected the Black Sea to a galaxy of inland ports. Second, portions – specifically the Bujak steppe and the region of the Danubian lakes – were ideal for winter camps… Since the Bronze Age, it was mostly a nomad’s land.”

p. 217 “In early 1313, with the lunar new year approaching, the hordes converged on the lower Volga for festicities and the entronement of their new khan. But no consensus had been reached. Ozbek learned … his opponents were preparing a coup against him. Upon hearing the news, he rushed out of his tent, gathered his men and allies on the outskirts of the festival site and then returned in full force… slayed Tukel Buqa, while Ozbek’s men killed the begs and princes who opposed him… Soon after taking the throne, Ozbek married his stepmother Bayalun. By doing so, he reestablished his deceased father in the direct lineal succession and tighted his own control over the ruling lineage. As a Muslim, Ozbek was forbidden from marrying his stepmother, but the Khan’s jurists circumvented the issue by claiming that Bayalun’s previous marriages were not valid because her former husnands had not been Muslim. .. She was no passive instrument of legitimation; on the contray, Bayalun had been at the center of power for more than 20 years, and she was keen to maintain her influence.” (reference DeWeese Islamization, 93-4, 120 https://www.jstor.org/stable/164043)

p. 237 By the 1330s continuing economic growth had transformed Sarai into a huge city. It took half a day on horseback to cross from one end to the other. Sarai had open space but also densely populated districts with uninterrupted rows of gardenless houses. They ran along large streets bordered with aryks, deep irrigation ditches, and water pipes most likely serving bathhouses and ceramics workshops … two kinds of pipes ran across the urban settlement: one, made of ceramic, supplied water, while the other, made of wood, carried sewage, which probably discharged into the Akhtuba. The city also had a number of wells that provided water for household use, although not for drinking. Drainage systems were a commonplace in Central Asian cities, likely well before the period of Mongol domination… Central Asian urbanites moved to the Volga region and built there the same infrastructure they were familiar with in their hometowns.”

p. 250 It turned out that the Ilkhanids’ gradual collapse between the 1330s and the 1350s was just a harbringer of the most consequential global political phenomenon of the 14th century, the disintregation of the Mongol Empire. The Horde succumbed to infighting, the ulus of Chagatay split, and the Yuan, the Toluid regime in the far east, was ejected from China. All these changes were hastened by the Black Death, which revealed weaknesses in the larger world system stewarded and relied on by Chingis’s heirs. With the global economy shattered by the pandemic, trade and ciculation – the lifeblood of the Chinggidis regimes, – drained away. By the end of the 14th century there was still a Horde, there was stilla Yuan dynasty, and there was still a people that called themselves the ulus of Chagatay, but all of these looked dramatically different from the sturdy politics of decades earlier.”

Books History Women's history

Notes from Condemned: The Transported Men, Women and Children who Built Britain’s Empire

p. 16 “The City of London, suffering from a “superfluous multitude of unwanted and troublesome children “appointed” one hundred of them to be taken to Virginia in 1620, “there to be bound apprentices, upon very beneficial conditions”. So anxious was the City to rid itself of this innocent excess that 500 shillings were granted “for their passage and outfit”. It seems tghat some of the children were relucant to go to an unknown land across dangerous seas. The City petitioned the Board of Trades and Plantations for a ruling to overcome what was, even then, a dramatic infringement of personal liberty. The argument made by the London authorities was based on the redemption “of the ill0disposed children” from the sin of existing. They argued that the children “under severe masters in Vriginia may be brough to goodness”. But without official sanction, the City was unable to dlivert the children to the Virginia Company for transportation against their will, desiring a “higher authority to get over the difficulty”. Of course a way was found … and so it was with all aspects of transportation. With or without the support of the law, valuable, preferably young bodies would be procured for the needs of the New World.

p. 17 Throughout the 1740s hundreds of children were said to have been disappeared from the Aberdeen area alone, as traders, authorities and New World planters took advantage of the poor, the orpohaned and the plain unlucky. The ill-favoured included those who did not fit in. As well as children, sturdy beggars, strolling players and their troublesome like, “Egyptians” as Roma people were then known, were transported. With their nomadic lifestyle and distinctive dress, they were always easy targets. They were banished from England as early as 1531, and a few years later, in 1544. These unfortunates were sent to continental Europe, but as the empire established its foundations and banishment evolved into transportation, the Americas provided new destinations. In 1665 an Edinburgh merchant, George Hutcheson, and his business partners were empowered by the Privy Council to transport loose and dissolute persons, including “Egyptians” to Barbados and Jamaica. A similar privilege was granted to an Edinburgh syndicate in 1669. Nearly 50 years later, in 1715, nine male and female Gypsies were sent to Virginia. Waht, if any, crimes, these people had committed, was usually unclear.”

p. 26 Marcellus Rivers and Oxenbridge Foyle, gentlemen, were two of more than 70 Royalist rebels from the Penddrock Rising transported to Barbados in 1656. They had fought with the wrong army and simply been sold into forced labour by Cromwell’s main financier. Plantation slavery was well established by this time and the planters were not particular about the exact legal status of their workers, slave, indentured labourer or convitc. They were all treated in much the same way, especially when it came to tending the fields. Ten to 12-hour days were standard with overseers using harsh punishments to enforce obedience and productivity. Sunday was the only day of rest. Observers at the time likened the working conditions to those of galley slaves, an unremitting regime of backbreaking work conducted a rate determined by the overseer. After being imprisoned at Exeter, eben though “many of them never saw Salisbury, nor bore arms in their lives” and underwent no legal process, let alone a trial, the men languished for a year. Then without warning, they were “snatched out of their prisons” and driven unger guard in carts through the city. After further movements, they sailed from Plymouth and arrived in Barbados nearly six weeks later”.. never till thy came to the island knew whither they were going”… These men became the “goods and chattels” of a couple of London aldermen and a captain of Plymouth… The petitioners asked the court “to question by what authority so great a breach is made upon the free people of England”… caused uproar among the public and in Parliament. . contributed to the view that colonial transportation was a system that enslaved English people, an affront to the popular notion of the “freeborn Englishman”. Widespread popular opposition to transportation stems largely from this period. Oxenbridge Foyle seems to be lost to history but we know that Marcellus Rivers reyurned to England. He took the opportunity of the restoartion of the monarchy in 1660 to bring a case against the previously well-connected planters and slavers who had trafficked hime and his companions, reducing them to “Barbados merchandize”. 
p. 34 Mary Moders, better known as Mary Carleton, specialised in relationships with middle- and upper-class men of substance, young and old, all ending with her disappearance, along with their wealth, whatever was left of it… in prison became such a celebrity that she was visited by the diarist Samuel Pepys, who also seems to have fallen under her spell… cleverly exploited her notoriety as far as she could, pursuing her serial relationships and frauds for some years, until arrested for stealing. The ‘princess’ was found guilty and transported to Jamaice in 1671. .. the service she provided in betraying her companions won Mary no favours for breaking the law against returning from banishment before serving the full sentence. . The playwright Aphra Behn procided a more sympathetic epitaph in the epilogue to her play The Dutch Lover, published shortly after Mary’s execution… Mary remained a celebrity, with street ballads and accounts of her adventures still being published and republished half a century after her execution. Her raffish life, brief transportation and ill-judged reuyrn highlight the haphazard nature of the system and the often random fates of those caught within it.”
p. 118 Japan – January 1830. “the men were escaped convicts. They had mutinied aboard the brig Cyprus in Recherche Bay, Van Diemen’s Land, five months earlier.. The 18 convicts aboard sailed bolding into the Pacific Ocean for a life of piuracy and plunder. Their only experienced sailor was a man who named himself after a free-flying bird, William Swallow. His real name was William Walker, though he had a long list of other crijminal aliases and a colourful record. Born in 1792, Walker was transported for stealing, arriving in Van Diemen’s Land in 1829… He escaped back to England, where he was eventially recaptured and tried under an alias, escaping a likely death sentence for returning from transportation… the Japanese decided to help them out with some advice about the weather and winds, allowing them to set sail and drift away to sea. … They managed to reach China, losing only one man overboard. Three more departed the crew and in February 1830 the remaining mutineers scuttled the Cyprus and took to the ship’s boat with the aim of pretending they were shipwrecked sailors. The authories in Canton believed their lies and the convicts scattered. Some headed for America never to be heard from again, but Swallow and three others sailed for England. While they were in transity, news of the mutiny on the Cyprus reached Canton and one of the convicts who had remained there confessed to the crime. A fast ship carried the news to England and when Swallow and his accompliced arrived there six days later the authorities were waiting. Swallow managed to escape but was recaptured… Two of Swallow’s accomplices were hanged but he escaped the noose by convincing the court that he had acted under intimidation and navigated the ship to save himself. He was found not guilty of piracy and sentenced to serve out the remainder of his sentence. For the third time he sailed to Van Diemen’s Land and arrived at the destination of his original voyage. He died in 1834 at another notorious prison a few years after returning to penal servitude. .. laid to rest in an unmarked grave on the Isle of the Dead, the Port Arthur cemetery.”

p. 148 Convictism was the inevitable obverse of a global imperial institution. At the top of the social order were the government, officials, penal authorities, the military, merchant traders and armies of administrators necessary to run such an extensive enterprise and its attendant bureaucracy. At the bottom were the poor, indigent, ciminal, rebellious and otherwise troublesome indviduals. The upper and lower spheres depended on each other for their continued existence in a twisted chain of mutual dependency.”

p. 158 Dudhnath Tewari was a sepot in the Bengal Native Infantry in Punjab when, along with many others, he deserted and joined the mutiny against British colonial rule. He was transported with others to Port Blair in the Andamans in 1858. A little more than six months later he was part of a mass escape… the fugitives met a harsh landscape and an enraged and dispossessed indigenous people, ,, Andamese … nursed him back to health and allowed him to effectively join their community. He hunted with them, took part in their religious ceremonies and married two Andamese women, one of whom, in due course, gave birth to a son. … a little over a year. One day he heard excited talk among his hosts about plans to rid their homeland of the British. He quickly discovered that this involved a massacre of everyone in the islands, not only the British but his own countrymen and other convicts… he returned to Port Blair with news of the attack. It came on 17 May at a place the British had named Aberdeen. Forewarned, British firepower easily repelled the determined attack by the poorly armed Andamanese, slaughering them in their thousands and perpetuating what was effectively a genocide. It was the end of indigenous resistsance and incited the British to consoludate their power throughout the Andaman and neighbouring Nicobar Islands. For his treachery – or was it bravery? – Tewari was later given a full pardon and reportedly returned to his home in northern India.”

p. 203 In July 1840 eight-year-old William Beale was sentenced at Lewes Assizes in Sussex to seven years transportation for larceny. He was described as a ‘laborer’. He landed in Fremantle from the Isle of Wight in October 1843. Presumably 11 years old by now, he was thought to be too small and weak to work as an apprentice and one of his employers said he had barely been able to carry half a bucket of water. William was quickly in trouble for neglecting his work, sleeping rough in the bush, absconding and “working on his own account”. He was also described by two of his “masters” as a good worker. Eventually, the boy was “paid off”, as the record described it, and was lasted reported to be earning good wages of two pounds a month as a shepher. Hopefully, his entrepreneurial character led him to prosper, although a “William Beale” received three months’ hard labour for perjury in 1876 and it is not impoosible that this was the Parkhurst boy, by then aged in his mid-40s.”

p. 224 “It is estimated that Britain transported over 376,000 convicts between 1615 and 1940. These included the vagrant poor; professional and other criminals; rebellious Irish, Scots and English; religious recalcitrants, sundry unrulies, including Gypsies, border reivers (raiders), pirates, military deserters and ‘superfuous multitudes’ of unwanted children. To this figure can be added the unknown numbers of adbucted as well as internally transported and re-transported peoples of the far-flung empire… one of history’s most prolonged and brutal forms of oppression and punishment… these human beings were seen as sources of colonial labour, markets and procreation. Over four centuries the various public and private interests involved in this trade evolved into an extensive and large-scale ‘system’ of global labour transfer built on human misery, of individuals being enmeshed in economic, ploitical, strategic and commercial forces beyond their control. Many died. A few escaped. Some prospered. Most did their time and then got on with life. BUt almost all suffered.

Books History Women's history

Notes from Women Artists in the Early Modern Courts of Europe c. 1450-1700

P. 39 As a woman’s respectability was inevitably dependent upon her status as a wife, it is little wonder that at least 70% of the female artists in the list were married, the real percentage was probably even higher since the material status of some remains unknown. Many of the women examined in this study were married to artists or members of a court… In the case of Anelika Kauffmann, it was reported that her husband cared for her interests like a manager. By contrast, the busbands of Roman-born Artemisia Gentileschi and the French Elisabeth Vigee Le Brun squandered their wives carefully managed gains, an abuse which led in both cases to separation. Unmarried female artists appear to have been generally accepted as is demonstrated by the notable example of the 18th-century Venetian artist Rosalba Carriera, who remained single throughout her life. (A further example is Madeleine Francoise Basseport). Remarkably, only half the married female court artists researched here appear to have had children. Whether this statistic is a result of gaps in the available documentation or a conscious decision to forego having children remain a subject of speculation.

P. 43 Lavinia Fontana, a native of Bologna, may be taken as an example of a female artist who followed in Sofonisba Anguissola’s footsteps. Unlike Anguissola, Fontana did not come from a noble family but rather an artistic one. Nonetheless, she sought to style herself upon an aristocratic model in order to demonstrate her suitability for a court appointment. Fonatan who, according to a 17th-century source, acquired a doctorate from the University of Nologna, presented herself as a highly refined and well-educated lady. She appears in elegant attire, seated at her desk and surrounded by a collection of antiques. She is not engaged in the potentially messy act of painting, but is rather just beginning to sketch her ideas on paper.

P. 45 Another career strategy was to capitalise upon the perceived novelty of the female artist…. Some female artists reinforced their exotic status by developing unusual artistic techniques. The Italian artist Giocanna Garzoni, who was famed for her still-life paintings, originated an innovative painting technique using a multitude of single-coloured dots, which resulted in an aesthetically pleasing pointillist effect. Rosalba Carriera had great success in adopting the medium of pastels, innovative in the early 18th century. The Dutch 17th-century artist Johanna Koerten made court protraits in the form of extremely fine, filagreed paper silhouettes. Her unique mastery of this unusual and difficult technique earned her high honour in the courts of Europe. Luisa Roldan, appointed court sculptor by the Spanish King Carlos II in 1692, mastered the physically demanding art of woodcarving, rarely practiced by women, and innovated in creating terracotta sculpture at court. .. Rachel ruysch, court painter to Prince Johann Wilhelm von der Pfalz, delighted the court in Dusseldorf with her minutely detailed and realistic still-life compositions. She also remained active until a very advanced age, a marvel that Ruysch emphasized by both signing and dating her works. 

P. 52 Misogynist criticism was certainly not lacking. Many female artists were accused of succeeding only on the basis of their femininity. The English painter Nathaniel Hone, for example, insinuated this in his painting The Conjuror, which created a major scandal following its public display in 1775. The magician after whom the work is titled alludes to the British Academy’s president, Sir Joshua Reynolds, and is depicted with a young girl nestled up against his leg. The girl’s pose recalled a painting by Angelika Kauffmann, who was rumoured to have a relationship with Renolds… a highly compromising scene could be observed in the background. Before the silhouette of St Paul’s Cathedral  there appeared to be a bacchanalian dance in progress, with an attractive young woman at its centre, naked but for her boots. This scene referred to a 1773 commission to numerous Academy members who had been given the task of decorating the great London cathedral. Hone had not been among those chosen by Reynolds, though Kauffmann was.”

P.62 The highest genre of art, history painting, reamined the sole purview of male artists at court,.. The relatively high number of court appointments declined by women artists show that it was more attractive for them to strive for a balance between court and civil commissions. 

P. 105 “Sofonisba seems to have had a strong personality and force of will. And even though she did not serve Anne of Austria officially, the two seem to have forged a close relationship. This is suggested by Queen’s intercession in 1571 on Sofonisba’s behalf with Phillip II when the artists, along with a group of damas, was involved in an act of Household rebellion. On that occasion a group of ladies in waiting gathered trunks and pulled them against windows that had been closed with padlocks, by order of the King, to keep the ladies from contact with suitors or others… Philip II became very upset and threatened to send the ladies in waiting back to their families without dowry or wedding … It was the queen’s responsibility to decide what happened to them… While the offenders were briefly confined, Queen Anne allowed them out after a day and a half, despite the fact that the King considered the punishment insufficient. … another episode involving Sofonisba in which the damas, taking advantage of the absence of the king, snuck into his chambers and, using spearheads or metal, wrote on the windows.”

P. 139 Grand Duchess Vittoria della Rovere (1622-94) was an important patron of women artists and artisans at the Medici court whose impact on humanist culture has only recently begun to be explored in depth. .. training and education she provided for two embroiderers and lacemakers, Caterian Angiola Pieroncini and another woman known only to us by the moniker “La Trottolina” in the 1660s. Both ladies in waiting, the young women were sent to Paris to perfect their needlework skills in the new French styles. Having gained proficiency in France, both were repatriated to Florence. There they continued in service to the Grand Duchess, alongside other dame, among themMaria Maddalena Caligari, who were trained by nuns at the city’s convents.”

Related to a big digital project on women makers.

Books Early modern history History

Notes from The Gun, The Ship and The Pen

P. 46 “What happened on Saint-Domingue/Haiti also confirms the political impact and disruptiveness of expanding levels of warfare in the 1700s. It underlines, too, the degree to which this was not just a Western phenomenon. In much of west Africa, the middle decades of the 18th century also witnessed a plurality of conflicts. Take Dahomey, a formidable kingdom in present-day Benin, with its own standing army and gunpowder weaponry. In 1724, it soldiers invaded the once powerful coastal kingdom of Allada, sezing over 8,000 captives. Dahomey itself was invaded seven times between the 1720s and 1740s by the armies of the Yoruba Oyo empire. This was based in what is now Nigeria, and sometimes deployed armies of over 50,000 men, There were other conflicts in this huge region. In the declining kingdom of Kongo, a polity which extended into parts of what is now Angola, Gabon and the two republics of Congo, a longrunning civil war reached even sharper levels of violence between the 1760s and the 1780s…. Some Africanist have contended “a great many of the slaves” who were shipped by French slavers into Saint-Somingue in the later 1700s may in effect have been military veterans, men who had ‘served in African armies prior to their enslavement … may have been … speculates the historian John Thornton,… “the key element of the early success” of its revellion in the 1790s against slavery, and that enabled the Black insurgents here to endure and fight back when they were “threatened by reinforced armies from Europe”.”

P. 67 “Celebration of Moses, along with other real and legendary legislators such as Lycurgus, the quasi-mythical lawgiver of ancient Sparta, Charlemagne, Muhammad, Confucius and the Anglo-Saxon King Alfred found enhanced expression from the mid-18th century not only in political, philosophical and scholarly writing, but also in art and in architectural design and sculpture. The growing cult of messianic lawmkers even surfaces in nobels – in Louis-Sebastien Mercier’s utopian bestseller L’An 2440 (1770) for instance… Mercier imagined a 25th century Mesico that has been cleansed of colonial violence by a Black “avenger of the New World”. This hero fights successfully against European predators, but Mercier goes on to describe how “this great man, this renowned legislator, this negro in whom nature had exerted all her force subsequently lays down the dword and instead resolves to display to the nation the sacred code of the laws, devising a federal constitution and becoming in the process a model for his fellow rulers.”

P. 75 Catherine the Great “those at the time and since who dismiss the Nakaz as nothing more than a vain autocrat’s parade of her pretensions to enlightenment have also misread and misunderstood its significance. It was innovative and influential not least in terms of the techniques that Catherine devised in order to advance and promote it. The Legislative Commission that met in Moscow in August 1767 … brought together delegates froman entire, rapidly expanding overland empire… far less power and initiative than America’s Founding Fathers; and, in the end, they accomplished much less… markedly more diverse in terms of social, economic, religious and ethnic background than the men of Philadelphia. About 30% were nobles, but some came from much lower down the social hierarchy… a man needed only to own a house or possess a trade. Women too received some recognition in this Moscow commission, something that did not happen in revolutionary America, or revolutionary France, or in revolutionary Haiti or revolutionary Spanish America. Among those selecting the commission’s members in 1767 were female landowners who were able to vote by proxy … did nothing for Russia’s own slave population, the roughly 50% of its peasant class who were serfs. Catherine had initially planned to use the Nakaz to ease the condition of these people and provide for their gradual emancipation… but these emancipatory projects fell victims to objections from the landowning class, and to her own nervousness about alienating her nobility.. Not all of the Moscow deputies were white, and not all of them were Christian. The empire’s non-Russian peoples, many of whom were Muslims, had been dran on extensively for military service during the Seven Years’ War. They reaped some reward in the Legislative Commission where they were allotted 54 deputies. “Orthodox sits next to heretic and Muslim,” wrote Catherine complacently in December 1767 of the commission’s meetings, “and all three listen calmly to a heathen; and all four often put their heads together to make their opinions mutually acceptable.”

P. 116 The Federalist Papers, these essays are probably best known now for Hamilton’s initial euphoric boast: “It seems to have been reserved to the people of this country… to decide the important question, whether societies of men are really capable or not of establishing good government from reflection and choice, or whether they are forever destined to depend for their political constitutions on accident and force.”

P. 127 The new American political texts also confirmed and accelerated those changes in understandings of the term ‘constitution’ that were already emerging before 1776. It became more common now to argue that political constitutions might – perhaps even should – be set down in a single, easy-to-print document. One sign of this shift is the response of opponents. From the 1780s, conservatives in some of the disparate German lands and in Brityain began to refer derisively to ‘paper constitutions’. 

P. 135 Men and women who were interested in this form of political technology were increasingly presented with a choice. Not only could they study and plunder the United States’ own much reproduced and translated texts. Progressively, they were also in a position to secure information about, and read, and rifle the constitutions of other places. Already by the 1790s, savvy publishers had recognised and were beginning to capitalise on this trend.. Began to issue omnibus collections of constitutions… by the early 20th century, indeed, some newly emerging states and regimes were themselves sponsoring and publishing these kinds of collections… what happened in 1922 in the new Irish Free State, precariously established after six years of civil warfare against the British. The Free State government in Dublin commissioned and issued a hefty volume entitled Select Constitutions of the World. With the text of its own new Irish constitution printed prominently in fist place, the book also contained the texts of 18 other countries’ current constitutions.”

P. 138 The 1814 text crafted at Eidsvoll was painstakingly investigated by a Victorian scholar, the Swedish jurist Nils Hojer.. He was able to uncover and identify influences… “and in some cases verbatim translations – from the French revolutionary constitutions of 1791, 1793 and 1795, the American Federal Constitution and several state constitutions, the Polish Constitution of 1791, the Batavian [Dutch] constution of 1798, the Swedish of 1809 and the Spanish of 1812… what these men stoically hammered out as they waited for Swedish armed forces to arrive in their country was emphatically not a pure domestic invention… nor from any single foreign source… printed copies of the new constitution were put on sale in 1814 in Norway’s 25 major post offices and close to 100 sub-post offices… Norwegians were also encouraged to paste pages from these print version of the constitution on the inside walls of their houses thereby – quite literally – domesticating the country’s new politics and making it part of their everyday lives.”

P. 163 The common soldiery of Ancien Regime Europe (and elsewhere) were rarely the downtrodden automata of legend… Nonetheless, it is clear that some French Revolutionary troops were politicised to a quite different level, in part because widely distributed written and printed constitutions now existed to serve as instructional and inspiring scripts. Take Joseph-Louis-Gabriel Noel, a yeoman farmer and quiet family man from the still quieter village of Ubexy in north-eastern France. When he signed up as an infantryman in a local battalion of volunteers in August 1791, he quickly came to represent himself, even in the privacy of his letters home, as a “solider of the constitution”, a child of destiny. .. What he read, saw, heard and was told by his officers convinced him, however, that triumph was assured and not just for France. “It is we,” he rejoiced, “who must attack to send shivers down the tyrants’ spines and free enslaved people.”

P. 164 “The army that Hapoleon let loose on Russia in the summer of 1812 consisted of about 680,000 men, over half of whom were not French by birth. .. one Abdel-Talut. Originally captured in Ethiopia and sold as a slave in Cairo, he was pluched from captivity there by Napoleon’s invading soldiery, and subsequenly exposed to different forms of hardship and duress, taking part in several French military campaigns before dying in frozen agony on the retreat from Moscow.”

P. 193 “By the mid 1820s, Spain’s Atlantic empire had shrunk to just Cuba and Puerto Rico. The new independence constitutions crafted in Argentina in 1826, in Chile and Peru in 1828, and in New Granada, Urguay and Venezuela in 1830 still retained, however, strong traces of the original Cadez model. … because of his invasion of the Iberian peninsula, and because of the complex repercussions of his Bayonee Statute, Napoleon helped to foster the spread of written constitutions into the length and breadth of South America and the spread of knowledge of them into parts of south-east Asia.

P. 207 Pentham “also made contact with Islamic north Africa, especially by way of his ‘adopted son’, Hassuna D’Ghies. Madrasa-educated, multilingual and a devout Muslim, D’Ghies came from a wealthy family in Tripoli. Visiting London in the early 1820s, he quickly made himself known to Bentham and for over a year the two men worked on plans for an Arabic language constitution for Tripoli and for a wider political revolution that might range across north Africa. One result was Bentham’s 1822 essay “Securities Against Misrule”, the first full-length discussion by a Western author of how the new constitutional ideas and apparatus might be adapted to an Islamic polity.”

P. 208 Betham “back in 1789, when drafting a proposal for a constitution for Revolutionary France, he had argued for the extension of its franchise to all citizens ‘ male or female’ so long as the recipients were ‘of full age, of cound mind, and able to read’. Aware that even most of his fellow reformers would likely question ‘Wht admit women to the right of suffrage?’ Bentham pushed the counter-question: ‘Why exclude them? By the 1820s, however… this cause dropped out of his major public statements and writings. Time was short for him now, and there seemed so much that he could do.”

P. 415 (1820s to 1920s) “Unable or unwilling to design and deploy a formal written constitution, British jurists, polemicists and politicians resorted instead and deliberately to another form of print: patriotic and widely distributed and exported histories of their real and imagined political constitution.”

P. 342 James Africanus Beale Horton – surgeon-major and constituionalist 

P. 422 “In a deeply uncertain, shifting, unequal and violent world, therse kinds of imperfect but sometimes stirring, diversely useful and easily available texts may be the best we can hope for. As Thomas Jefferson put it in 1802: “tho’ written constitutions may be violated in moments of passion or delusion, yet they furhish a text to which those who are watchful may again rally and recall to the people.” Over 200 years later, much the same point was being acted out by a.. Young woman named Olga Misik who was protecting in the streets of Moscow…A pro-democracy activist, Misik found herself early in AUgust 2019 encircled by riot police, formidable men in body armour, brandishing shields and batons. Her response was to sit down in the street and read aloud passages from the pages of a paperback copy of the Russian constituion. Misik was 17 at this point and still at school… they did not move in and attack.”

Books Environmental politics History

Notes from Planet of the Bugs: Evolution and the Rise of Insects

P. 18 “The Cambrian period has generally been called the “age of invertebrates”. That’s certainly not because anyone sought to glorify our invertebrate ancestry. It’s simply an observation that we didn’t initially see any of our vertebrate ancestors in fossils from Cambrian layers. Notice that we didn’t bcall it the “age of arthropods” or the “age of trilobites”, either of which would be apt. Calling it the “age of invertebrates” is a bit like calling it the “age of no humans”. The name subtly derides the success of arthropods by noting the absence of vertebrates rathar than touting the evolution of exoskeletons. But subsequently we did discover our likely vertebrate ancestor in Cambrian times, and what a humbling event that was. A small creature called Pikaia was discovered in the 515-million-year-old Burgess Shale fossils of Canada. Pikaia was a mere one and a half inch long worm-like creature that burrowed in bottom sediments. She was soft-bodied, but did have an internal supporting structure, a primitive notochord, the ancestral structure of a vertebral column. Pikaia is now regarded as the most likely common ancestor of fish, amphibians, reptiles, dinosaurs, birds, and mammals. But she was such a modest ancestor that nobody lobbied for a renaming of the Cambrian as the “age of Pakaia.. P. 19 “in the waters above, along cruised animals like Anomalocaris, a three-foot-long nightmarish predatory arthropod with long spiny feeding appendages. Anomalocaris paddled along in Cambrian seas, picking off whatever small animals it could catch – do doubt feasting on lots of trilobites. From time to time, Anomalocaris no doubt swooped down to pick off a tender Pikaia for dinner… there is evidence that some trilobites may have been predatory … but still, if Cambrian trilobites had become extensively predatory, then it’s exceedingly unlikely we would be here to pierce together this story.”

P. 71 “Examples of paleopteran insects (a term that means “old wings”), mayflies are among the oldest surviving insects with the most ancient sort of wing design. … a relict that developed flight about 330 million years ago in the Carboniferous times. .. The front wings are much larger than the back and provide most of the lift for flight. All four wings are simple, however, in that they are capable of moving only up and down: mayflies don’t have the ability to flex and twist their wings at the base, as most modern insects are able to do… Mayflies are not very strong or adept fliers. They can dod little more than flutter their wings and drift and glide in easy patterns. Birds catch them easily, and fish eat their fill as mayflies land on water. Yet all the predators in the neighbourhood can’t make a dent in a mayfly swarm… Immediately after mating, the female flies back to the lake, then lands and floats on the surface. If she is lucky enough not to be eaten by a fish, the mother mayfly quickly dumps her eggs into the water as she dies. The eggs sink to the bottom and the cycle of death and rebirth is repeated, just as it has been for 320 million years.”

P. 75 “In the early Carboniferous, most of today’s macroscopic and microscopic consumers of dead wood had not yet evolved. There were no birds, mammals, bees, wasps, bark beetles, wood-boring beetles, bark lice, termites or ants. Moreover, during the Devonian and Carboniferous times, plants became very tall by producing cellulose and lignin, which are very difficult for animals to digest. None of the earliest invests were able to digest raw wood as well. The giant Carboniferous horsetails, like modern horsetails, toughened their vascular tissues with large amounts of silica, making them virtually indigestible. So the late Devonian and Carboniferous really were special for their excess production of plant materials, not only because the moist climate and high levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide favoured plant growth, but also because plants were able to produce more biomass than the herbivores could consume, for millions of years. The first important insect wood consumers – the wood roaches – did not appear until the Late Carboniferous. They were followed by the appearance of bark live and the diversification of wood-boring beetles in the PErmian. Over time, increasingly more complex communities of wood consumers evolved, and the global bulk production of plant materials of the Carboniferous has never been repeated.”

P. 87 During the Late Carboniferous, the giant griffenflies started chasing a new kind of insect that was tasty but harder to catch than the old net-winged ones. Neoptera, or the new-winged insects, were faster fliers and they had an original trick made possible by tiby articulating skeletal plates, called axillary, sclerites, in the membrane near their wing base. These allowed directional wing movements … they could twist their wings at the base, fold them back over their body, and put them away, making the neoptera much smaller than the older insects, which held their wings constantly outstretched, kitelike. … some were quick on their feet too. Quicky after landing, they would deftly fold their wings and run under a leaf or into cracks and crevices, making themselves tough targets for the air dragons. This was such a successful adaptation that before you could say “cockroach”, the tropical world was infested with them. Several groups of new-winged insects appeared during the Carboniferous, but the roaches (order Blattaria) were by far and away the most successful.. BY the Late Carboniferous there were more than 800 species, and they made up about 60% of the known Carboniferous insects… in terms of species diversity, we should probably call the Carboniferous period the “age of roaches”.

P. 90 “The wood roaches evolved a symbiotic relationship with their gut microorganisms and became the first effective macroconsumers of dead wood. The roaches in turn were the most abundant food source for a host of predators, including scorpions, spiders, centipedes, fish, amphibians, reptiles and the flying air dragons. So with the onset of the roaches an important turn occurred in the cycling of organic molecules. More biomass from plant material escaped the geological cycles of sedimentation and rock formation, and was cycled back into the living world by small animals. The great coal age was coming to an end.”

P. 114 “”Perhaps we can pick one singular moment when the Paleozoic era came to an end. I’d choose the particular day when the final trilobite died. What other creature better symbolises the entire era than the tribolute. Their reign in the oceans lasted for more than 300 million yeas, but some 252 million years ago, on a cloudy morning perhaps, the last one stopped feeding in a shallow tidal pool. Her body floated to the surface, and the retreating tide washed it ashore along with other trilobite carcasses…. There were no birds on that lonely beach, but there was a scurry of small feet,, as first one cockroach, then another, found the castaway body and consumed it. Maybe a lone beetle, preening its antennae on a log nearby, briefly flew down to inspect the scene and partake in the feast. Then it turned, unfolded its wings, and buzzed clumsily into the forest.”

P. 142 “Termites are often regarded as social cockroaches… it is generally agreed that termites evolved from roachlike ancestors, The key to termite behaviour and existence is the their ability to 

Digest cellulose from woody plants. Like their near cousins the wood roaches, they accomplished this difficult fear by housing symbiotic organisms in their digestive tracts. Like all other insects, they have an external skeleton, and their foregut and hindgut are lined with skeletal materials., Therefore, when they periodically molt their skeletons, termites lose their symbionts as well, and they must acquire new ones or else they will starve to death. They get their symbiotic gut microorganisms by a process called anal trophylaxis – literally by earting the feces of other termits.. Without ti some of the world’s most impressive and influential societies might never have evolved… solves another serious problem of subsisting in large societies: sewage removal.. Termites avoided all of this not only by eating their feces but also by using it to build tunnels and arches within their nests.”

P. 156 “The flowering plants, the blossom and fruit-producing organisms known to botanists as angiosperms, may have first evolved in the Jurassic period or earlier, but they were initially rare woody shrubs restricted to wet forest habitats. We have fossil flower pollen dating from the Early Cretaceous, 134 million years ago, and fossil leaves and flowers dating to 124 million years ago, and we know that by 120 million years ago the first angiosprems, including such recognisable species as water lillies and magnolias, quickly radiated and diversified. By the Middle Creatacsous, and on to the present day, angiosperms had become the dominant plant species… sweet nectar and nutritious pollen allowed flowers – and insects – to overrun the planet. Plants produce them in sacrificial abundance, enough to feed ravenous hordes of flies, beetles, wasps and moths … until the Cretaceous, their distribution was limited mostly by the constraints of wind pollination. But with the insects’ assistance – and thanks to the energetics of insect flight – plants at this time could spread their genetic material over long distances. Now they could exist as widely dispersed populations, scattered in forests with little wind movement.”

Books History

Notes from Kate Crawford’s Atlas of AI

p. 13 “The underlying visions of the AI field do not come into being autonomously, but instead have been constructed from a particular set of beliefs and perspectives. The chief designers of the contempoary atlas of AI are a small and homogenous group of people, based in a handful of cities, working in an industry that is currently the wealthiest in the world. Like medieval European mappae mundi, which illustrated religious and classical concepts as much as coordinates, the maps made by the AI industry are political interventions, as opposed to neutral reflections on the world.”

p. 16 Since antiquity, the business of mining has only been profitable because it does not have to account for its true costs: including environmental damage, the illness and death of miners, and the loss to the communities it displaces. In 1555, Georgius Agricola, known as the father of mineralogy, observed that “it is clear to all that there is greater detriment from mining than the value of the metals which the mining produces.”

p. 31 The mining that makes AI is noth literal and metaphorical. The next extractivism of data mining also encompasses and propels the old extractivism of traditional mining. The stack required to power artificial intelligence systems goes well beyond the multilahered technical stack of data modeling hardware, srevers and netwroks.. reaches into capital, labor and Earth’s resources… the cloud is the backbone of the artificial intelligence industry, and its made of rocks and lithium brine and crude oil”

p. 35 According to the computer manufacturer Dell, the complexities of the metals and mineral supply chain pose almost insurmountable challenges to the prodiction of conflict-free electronics components. The elements are laundered through such a vast number of entities along the chain that sourcing their provenance proves impossible 0 or so the end-product manufacturers claim, allowing them a measure of plausible deniability for any exploitative practices that drive their profits.”

p. p. 38 At the end of the 19th century, a particular Southeast Asian tree called the laquium gutta became the center of a cable boom. These trees, found mainly in Malaysia, produce a milky white natural latex called hutta-percha… rapidly became the darling of the engineering world … the solution to the problem of insulating undersea telegraphic cables to withstand harsh and varying conditions on the ocean floor. The twisted strands of copper wire needed four layers of the soft, organic tree sap to protect fhem from water intrusion and carry their electrical currents… The historian John Tully describes how local Malay, Chinese, and Dayak workers were paid little for the dangerous work of felling the trees and slowly collecting the latex. … as media scolar Nicole Starosielski writes, “Military strategists saw cables as the most efficient and secure mode of communication with the colonies – and, by implication, of control over them…. The jungles of Malaysia and Singapore were stripped: by the early 1880s the Palquium gutta had vanished.In a last-ditch effort to save their supply chain, the British passed a ban in 1883 to halt harvesting the latex, but the tree was all but extinct.”

p. 8 I argue that AI is neither artificial nor intelligent. Rather, artificial intelligence is both embodied and material, made from natural resources, fuel, human labour, infrastructure, logistics, histories and classifications. AI systems are not autonomous, rational, or able to discern anything without extensive, computationally intensivetraining with large datasets or pre-defined rules and rewards. In fact, artificial intelligence as we know it depends entirely on a much wider set of political and social structures. And due to the capital required to build AI at scale and the ways of seeing that it optimizes, AI systems are ultimately designed to serve existing dominent interests. In this sense, artificial intelligence is a registry of power.”

p. 42 ” Strubell’s team found that running only a single NLP [natural language processing] model produced more than 660,000 pounds of carvon dioxide emissions, the equivalent of five gas-powered cars over their total lifetime (including manufacturing) or 125 roundtrip flights from New York to Beijing.”

p. 56 Instead of asking whether robots will replace humans, I’m interested in how humans are increasingly treated like robots and what this means for the role of labour.. people are often performing rote tasks to shore up the impresssion that machines can do the work.”

p. 63 the experiences of crowdworkers who perform the repetitive digital tasks that underly AI systems, such as labelling thousands of hoursof training data and reviewing suspicious or harmful content. Workers do the repetitive tasks that backstop claims of AI magic, but the rarely receive credit for making the systems function.”

p. 76 Dominos Pizza has added to its kitchens machine -vision systems that inspect a finished pizza to ensure the staff made it according to prescribed standards. Surveillance apparatuses are justified for producing inputs for algorithnic scheduling systems that further modulate work time, or to glean behavioural signals that may correlate with signs of high or low work performance, or meerely sold to data brokers as a form of insight”

p. 159 Given that facial expressions are culturally variable, using them to train machine learning systems would inevitably mixtogether all sorts of different contexts, signals and expectations.

p. 173 None of these serious questions about the basis for Ekman’s claims have stopped his work from attaining a priileged role in current AI applications. Hundreds of papers cite Ekman’s view of interpretable facial expressions as tought it wer unproblematic fact, despite decades of scientific controversy. Few computer scientists have even acknowledged this literature of uncertainty”.

p, 174 WWht, with so many criticisms, has the approach of “reading emotions” from the face endured? .. we can begin to see how military research funding, policing priorities and profit motives have shaped the field…theories seemed ideal for the emerging field of computer vision because they could be automated at scale… powerful institutional and corporate investments in the validity of Ekman’s theories or metholodogies. Recognizing that emotions are not easily classified, or that they’re not reliably detectable from facial expressions, could undermine an expanding industry… the more complex issues of context, conditioning, relationaity and cultural factors are hard to reconcile with the current disciplinary approaches of computer science or the ambitions of the commercial tech sector. “

p. 206 when AI systems are deployed as part of the welfare state, they are used primarily as a way to surveil, assess, and restrict people’s access to public resources rather than as a way to provide for greater support… Michigan … “a matching algoriyjm be used to implement the state’s ‘fugitive felon’ policy, which sought automatically the disqualify indvidiuals from food assistance based on outstanding felony warrants. Between 2012 and 2015, mthe new system inaccurately matched from than 19,000 Michigan residents and automatically disqualified each of these from food assistance… in essence these systems are punitive, designed on a threat-targetting model.

p. 211 ARtificial intelligence is not an objective, universal, or neutral computational technique that makes determinations without human direction. Its systems are embedded in social, political, cultural and economic worlds, shaped by humans, institutions and imperatives that determine what they do and how they do it. They are designed to discriminate, to amplify hierarchies, and to encode narrow classifications. When applied in social contexts such as policing, the court system, health care and education, they can reproduce, optimize and amplify existing structural inequalities. This is no accident: AI systems are built to see and interven in the world in ways that primarily benefit the states, insutitutions and corporations that they serve.”

p. 226 What happens … if we begin with the commitment to a more just and sustainable world? How can we intervene to address interdependent issues of social, economic and clamte injustice. Where does technology serve that visions. And are there places where Ai should not be used, where it undermines justice? This is the basis of a renewed politics of refusal – opposing the narratives of techological inevitability that says ‘If it can be done, it will be.’ Rather than asking where Ai will be applied, merely because it can, the empasis should be on why it ought tho be applied … we can question the idea that everything should be subject to the logics of statistical prediction and profit accumulation, what Donna Haraway terms “the informatics of domination”.