Category Archives: Politics

Feminism

Motherhood or attention?

An irritatingly vague piece in the Observer today (couldn’t they have managed a figure or two in it?) finds that Pregnancy focuses girls’ minds on education. The line is that girls who get pregnant are often those who are disillusioned with or who have already left school, but after pregnancy they go back to school and work towards a professional future for themselves.

Seems sensible enough, and it is always good to see “teen mums” not just being regarded as a welfare burden. But I can’t help wondering if it is pregnancy precisely that has this effect, or the attention and services offered.

If you got to these girls before they were pregnant and offered the same services, would you not get a similar outcome? And without the babies…?

Environmental politics

Food faults and findings

The Observer today has an interesting piece about Green & Blacks ‘Maya Gold’ chocolate – there’s all the romantic stuff (well yes it is fun) about forgotten colonial plantations reclaimed from the jungle etc, but within its depths is the now all-too-familiar story about a food success story that immediately contains the seeds of its own destruction.

I hadn’t realised just how bad conventionally grown chocolate is:

In Ghana, every tree is doused – by law – with chemicals to keep diseases at bay. In Brazil, cacao is an industrialised crop grown on vast plantations in regimented rows, with insufficient shade and treated with artificial fertilisers and pesticides. This has not stopped, but rather spread, a pandemic of witches’ broom – a fungal disease caused by poor tree maintenance, described by Craig Sams as ‘the BSE of cacao’ – across South America. ‘They have pushed nature to its limits,’ says Sams, ‘and the industrialised model does not work.’

But there’s nothing like enough organic/Fair Trade for demand, and you can’t just switch supply on like a tap. So what usually happens – as did with coffee – once this new market is developed there’s a huge demand, high price, then the inevitable surge in the supply and dive in the price …

What is this solution to this? Perhaps realism among aid agencies/firms, even some discussion among them (but then that will run foul of competition law, most likely) and consumers not rushing from fad to fad.

But for the NHS the answer to an apparent conundrum is more obvious – cash or quality? Burger King or a friendly volunteer with a shoulder to cry on?

Hospital cafes staffed by volunteers who offer cheap drinks and snacks – and a sympathetic ear – could soon be consigned to history. Dozens of NHS trusts, faced with mounting deficits, are bringing in burger bars and cafes run by high-street chains to earn more from higher rents.

Joined up government anyone? I suspect the food served by those cafes isn’t all great in nutritional terms, but no doubt the service is, and Burger King is certainly not going to be a nutritional improvement.

Finally yet another argument against biotechnology – women who consume animal products, specifically dairy, are five times more likely to have twins. And there’s a jump in the rate (which seems not to be able to be explained by other factors such as reproductive technology) when growth hormone treatment of cattle for increased yields becomes widespread in the US. Makes you do wonder about the other effects of the hormone.

Politics

The underfunded Aboriginal community

It is the common claim made in the Australia (as around the world with regard to many disadvantaged groups) that the Aboriginal community has received extremely high levels of funding, and the “fact” that there is little to show for this investment is its failing, not that of the general community.

It is one of those assumptions seldom put to the test, but in the case of one community – Wadeye in the Northern Territory, which has been in the news recently for all of the wrong reasons – it has been. The results are telling:

Governments had spent far less per head on an Aboriginal person in Wadeye than on the average territorian – almost $2000 a year less. Wadeye, the sixth-largest town in the territory, was being short-changed to the tune of $4 million a year. Less was spent there despite the region’s average life expectancy being 46, despite an average 16 people living in each dwelling, and despite high levels of sickness, unemployment and illiteracy…

Governments spent 47 cents on a school-aged child in Wadeye for every dollar spent on an average territorian child. And compared with spending on schools in large urban areas such as Darwin, the real figure could be five cents.

The results are pretty much what you’d expect.

Books Environmental politics

A tale of the end of 20th-century hopes

Far too many writers with hopes of being labelled “literary” believe achieving that status requires them to pile in the adjectives and adverbs, to describe their hero’s every twitch and turn, the leaf of every tree she sits under, the state of every cloud above. Such writers should be sentenced to read Everyman’s Rules for Scientific Living, the Orange Prize-shortlisted first novel of the Australian Carrie Tiffany.

“Spare”, “sparse”, “laconic” are the adjectives that might be applied to this account of one woman’s life in the Victoria Mallee, a wheat-growing that suffered the same fate as the American dustbowl states. As a veteran of the Australian bush, I can confirm that no form of expression could be more apt; words are mere occasional punctuation of a real bushies’ silence.

Yet sparse doesn’t mean thin; all of Australia’s 20th-century history is here – the struggle to find a workable relationship with an ancient continent, to come to terms with its place in Asia, two world wars, the Depression, stories that are indeed not just Australian, but universal.

read more »

Environmental politics

People just not getting it…

The people of  it’s-the-suburbs-really-but-let’s-pretend-it-is-the-countryside Thaxted, Essex, put out on average the most carbon dioxide per household of any area in the UK.

The average household in leafy, tidy Uttlesford spews 8,092kg of carbon dioxide each year, more than double the comparatively clean, green dwellings of Camden in London, which on average produce just 3,255kg of CO2.

…Each year the average home here produces CO2 emissions equivalent to taking a Boeing 747 to Australia and back.

… “There’s all these huge pads out in the sticks where they leave their lights on all night and their big tellies on. That’s where it’s happening,” said Joe Hobbs, an architect.

The story goes on to say that those who have tried to do the right thing in terms of installing solar and wind power have run into problems with conservation and planning rules. The area obviously just doesn’t get it; all those lovely twisted old wood-framed buildings with thatched roofs won’t survive long underwater.

Then, you do have to feel sorry for this guy:

AN AIRLINE has apologised to a teacher after a short flight home to Manchester from France took more than 30 hours on a zigzagging journey on two aircraft, two coaches and a taxi, passing through five airports in three countries.

But then again, he was travelling from Angers, in the Loire Valley. It probably would have taken two hours on the train to Paris (if that) and three hours on Eurostar – and he would have been home probably quicker than the plane, even had things gone according to plan. And with far lower carbon emmissions. As a teacher, he should know better.

Finally, Australia has been hit by “drought” again. I put the word in quote marks, because when I studied agricultural science many years ago, I was told the definition of drought is exceptional weather conditions. Yet large parts of Australia are, according to farmers and officials, in “drought” for much of the time.

In fact, they are in denial about the actual normal (and quite possibly likely to get drier with global warming) climate of Australia. They’re trying to grow crops and run animals – at least the wrong sort of animals – in places where more often than not they’ll be in trouble.

Unfortunately I haven’t got a copy of it, but I once wrote an article interviewing an academic who maintained the only sensible form of “farming” across a majority of Australia was running kangaroos – leave the native pastures to maintain their own natural balance, let the roos have the run of the place (they have soft feet, not the hard hooves of the non-native ungulates, which chop up the soil and cause erosion), and harvest them once a year.

Environmental politics Miscellaneous

Shopping at the “low” and “high” ends

I was in my local Londis (corner store chain) last week (it has a half-way decent range of organics, extremely rare in a corner store), when I noticed some peanut cookies, definitely not organic but in the cheap and hopelessly morish class.

But they were 99p each; I used to get three for a pound of exactly the same thing from the Leather Lane street market. So I left them on the shelf.

But I was reminded of this by a report in the Independent today.

Local street markets generate twice as many jobs as big supermarkets and sell goods at half the price of the supposedly cut-price retail giants, research shows.

Planning decisions that favour the building of huge outlets over established smaller markets could result in fewer jobs and less choice for local communities, a report by the think-tank the New Economics Foundation (NEF) warned.

Leather Lane thrives because it gets lots of office workers, but the markets in this part of Camden (Chalton and Plender Streets) are struggling, and further north the council has been trying to move them out altogether to use the sites for, you guessed it, luxury flats. What is needed is some lateral thinking to mix the traditional cheapie traders with more of the organic, “farmers’ market” type, I’d suggest. Oh, and make sure you genuinely block off the traffic – not done in either Chalton or Plender streets.

Moving to the other end of the market, found intriguing a story in the Telegraph about bespoke tailored bras.

‘Women who come to me think there is something wrong with them. “I have to talk to you,” they say. “I’m not normal,” and they are 36B. 36B is normal – it is the bra that isn’t normal! ‘Bras are the most difficult item of clothing to make,’ she continues. ‘More than shoes, more than hats. But the manufacturers don’t respect the bra. They make something only to cover the nipple. Our business is to support the bust. It’s not just to cover it.’ According to Poupie, the worst offenders are ‘seamless bras in elastic or stretchy fabrics – the women who wear these bras today are my customers of tomorrow! Stretchy straps are bad, too.’

Food for thought there…