Monthly Archives: December 2006

Environmental politics Feminism

Decriminalisation is the only way to safety

Over on The Daily (Maybe) Jim sets out the thinking behind the Green Party policy on prostitution – decrimininalistion – so well that I won’t bother to repeat it.

He was prompted, as will be many commentators in the next few days, by the confirmation, if it were needed, that a serial killer has been targetting street sex workers in Ipswich: the death toll now has risen to five.

In the less likely surroundings of The Times, Alice Miles arrives at the same conclusion:

The solutions are too unpalatable for polite politics, which relies on middle-class votes in “nice” areas like Suffolk for election.
First, brothels: proper, clean, large-as-you-like, licensed knocking shops, with medical checks and protection for the girls. And tax credits too. Not all prostitutes would want to join one, but at least they would have a choice. At the beginning of this year Labour launched a “prostitution strategy”, after the most thorough review of the law in half a century. It abandoned ideas for managed zones in non-residential areas and instead prescribed a crackdown on kerb crawling, early intervention, efforts to tackle demand and new attempts to help women to escape from the lifestyle. It would be laughable if it weren’t so serious and so sad: a pathetic range of tried and failed “policies”. The only promising proposal was to allow up to three women to operate from the same premises in sort of mini-brothels without facing prosecution; but there has been no sign since of the legislation needed to implement it.

I’d add a still more radical line – we should stop regarding sex work as having any sort of stigma; should try very hard to remove any of our lingering Judeao-Christian hang-ups about sex. It should be a job choice like any other – and one that attracts exactly the same – indeed given the level of risk, higher, levels of health and safety protection. (I have no doubt that the rate of death and injury among sex workers is higher than that of any other line of work – higher than fishermen, building workers et al) .

Blogging/IT Environmental politics

How does this add to the sum of human happiness?

Reading those kinds of kitchen catalogues that include astonishing improbable gadgets designed to “take the hard work out of preparing a fruit salad/slicing an onion/pulling out the cling wrap/some other simple task” have long been a source of small innocent amusement.

But this really takes the biscuit:

LCD digital photo frame with bright 7″ display for your favourite digital images with customisable slide shows & MP3 music via built-in speaker
* Bright 7″ active matrix LCD display – 16:9 widescreen format
* Create customisable slide shows with music via intergal speaker
* MP3 music playback and MP4 video playback
* Supports SD/MMC card, xD card, MS and USB flash drive
* Clock and calendar with alarm and snooze functions
* Supplied with credit card style remote control and 3 interchangeable fascias

Could you possibly put together a more pointless collection of the latest electronic gadgets?

Well I suppose you could, but you’d have to try very, very hard.

Politics

The child abuse hysteria

An interesting article from America about the panic over paedophiles there. One surprising statistic, given the talk about the supposed difficulty of rehabilitating child sex offenders is the recidivism rate – just 5% re-arrested within three years, much lower than other crimes.

The tragic irony is that the panic over sex offenders distracts the public from the real danger, a far greater threat to children than sexual predators: parental abuse and neglect. The vast majority of crimes against children are committed not by released sex offenders but instead by the victim’s own family, church clergy, and family friends. According to a 2003 report by the Department of Human Services, hundreds of thousands of children are abused and neglected each year by their parents and caregivers, and more than 1,500 American children died from that abuse in 2003—most of the victims under four years old. That is more than four children killed per day—not by convicted sexual offenders or Internet predators, but by those entrusted to care for them…

Arts

Women with style

Over on My London Your London, Robert has a lovely review of a great-sounding band with four female members, Bat for Lashes. I’m not at all into music, but it sounds such fun I’m almost tempted to go along.

Bat For Lashes’ lyrics take us to a lavish dreamworld full of, well, all the things you’d expect in a lavish dreamworld: unicorns, wizards, pagan rituals in misty forests, that sort of thing. All this willful weirdness draws obvious comparisons with the likes of Kate Bush, Björk and Cat Power.

Environmental politics

Blaming the victim?

I’m currently reading Paul Farmer’s Infections and Inequalities: The Modern Plagues, for tomorrow night’s meeting of the Green Book Club that I’m probably now not going to make. (Sorry folks!)

I’ve anyway only read the first chapter, but its intellectual foundations, at the junction of participatory anthropology and medicine (the author being fully qualified in both), are spectacular illuminatory.

I’ve been musing all day on this passage:

This conflation of structural violence and cultural difference has marred much commentary on AIDS, especially when that commentary focuses on the chief victims of the disease: the poor. A related trend is the exaggeration of the agency of those most likely to become infected. Often such exaggeration is tantamount to blaming the victim. Explorations of AIDS have involved intense scrutiny of local factors and local actors, including the natives’ conceptions and stated motives. But it is possible to explain the distribution of HIV by discussing only attitude or cognition? After more than 15 years in Haiti, I would not hazard to comment on the psychological makeup specific to Haitians with AIDS… On the makeup of Haiti’s changing social conditions and their relation to Aids, however, much can be said. (p. 9 California Press 1999 edition)

It seemed particularly apt on a day when the Tories have found a new way to approach “back-to-basics”. They aren’t attacking single mothers this time – just cohabiting ones, and their partners for good measure. So the problems underlying the British underclass, in the Tory view, are economic – it is because they aren’t behaving, are exercising the limited agency available to them bady, by not trotting up to the altar. That nicely lets the economy and government off the hook then…

Books

A detective in the age of Henry VIII

Everything we know about the morality and behaviour of Tudor times suggests that we would find the character of many of the people then — certainly those battling their way in the cutthroat world of the royal court — unattractive. Yet CJ Samson, in creating his detective character, the hunchback lawyer Matthew Shardlake, has found a way around this problem. The man whose deformity is often openly mocked and even causes superstitious fear — the credible genuinely believe that seeing a person so deformed will cause bad luck — is sensitive to other’s pain. He also cannot react to difficult and dangerous situations by whipping out his sword, as your average Tudor man would have done – in fact is believably a lot more like us than almost any other Tudor character might be.

Master Shardlake makes his third appearance in a novel simply entitled Sovereign – appropriately enough, since while the massive figure of Henry VIII hovered menacingly in the background in the first two novels, here he is centre stage, dominating the thoughts of everyone, even in his absence, as he leads the great Progress of the North of 1541. Still seeking to avoid becoming entangled in the intrigues of the court, Master Shardlake is lured into a delicate mission by Archbishop Cranmer. He is to protect a valuable prisoner, who knows secrets that could shake the foundations of the throne, until that prisoner can be taken to London for the hideous but calculated ministrations of the professional torturers in the Tower of London.

A man who can’t even face watching a bear-baiting, Master Shardlake is troubled by this, as he also tries to deal with the recent death of his father. Sansom develops the lawyer’s character beautifully, although he’s less sure in his handling of female characters. Here Tamasin, a young woman of the court, an orphan having to look out for herself, is central to the plot – becoming entangled, it seems to the point of marriage, with Master Shardlake’s rough clerk and oft-time bodyguard, Barak. The lawyer is understandable uncertain about her, but as we only ever see her from his point of view, she never really develops.

The physical reality of early modern life – the clothes, the smell, the severed heads on spikes above town walls – are, however, all beautifully laid out, and the detailed research behind the novel is evident in the accounts of the run-down, angry city of York — still seething after the “Pilgrimage of Grace” rebellion a few years before.

The politics of the court, its intrigues and maneouvres, are also, so far as this reader can tell, closely based on historical reality, where it is known, and the fictional additions are well-crafted. We know, of course, what is going to happen to the king’s young fifth wife, Catherine Howard, but that adds to, rather than detracts from, the suspense. And the traditional final twist at the end of the novel is beautifully done.

I complained when I reviewed the second novel in the series, Dark Fire, that Sansom’s writing style sometimes grated, and here it has definitely improved. Fewer individual words grate, and while sometimes the research shines through just a little too much, it now feels more integrated into the story.

It is perhaps just a little too early to start talking about Sansom in the same breath as the great historical novelist Edith Pargeter (Ellis Peters), but he is certainly heading in that direction. But while Peters’ Brother Cadfael, created in the 20th century, lived in a neat, just-desserts world, Master Shardlake’s is altogether messier – moral and physically – suiting today’s tastes.