Monthly Archives: November 2008

Blogging/IT Carnival of Feminists

Drumroll please…

… the Carnival of Feminists No 68 is now up on Fourth Wave. And a superb collection from the feminist blogosphere it is too – if, hopefully, the last for a while to feature Sarah Palin.

This is, if memory serves me right, the first to feature Olympe de Gouge, wonders why some men only want to eat food cooked by women, and the post on “my neighbour’s sex life” explores some very interesting issues. (And really, I’m not just following the old journalist’s line of always getting sex in the headline.

And I’m looking for hosts for future carnivals – if you’re interested – and don’t be shy, you can be a new blogger, a long-time blogger, or anywhere inbetween – drop me a line: natalieben AT gmail DOT com.

While I’m here I’ll also mention that there’s a fine Britblog Roundup this week, just up the road from me in Islington, with Susanne.

And finally I say eon: here’s why.

Feminism

Women’s miscellany

An interesting survey about British women’s attitudes – yes it is in the Telegraph, and you have to slice through the shocked rightwingers commentary, but the figures would seem to be solid enough, and on one question at least, not great, but not awful…

Nearly two women in five (38 per cent) regards herself as a feminist and, surprisingly perhaps, the highest figure (41 per cent) is in the age group of 55 or more. The figure falls to 34 per cent for those aged 18 to 24.

(Possibly wisdom coming with age…)

And speaking of older women, a quite horrifying story from the Independent about the death of Brenda Hean, a Tasmanian anti-dam activist. It seems highly likely that her plane was sabotaged – and we’re only talking 1972 here, so it seems possible that those responsible might be still alive.

But on the good news front, the women’s rugby world cup is coming to Britain in 2010. (Which will give me an excuse to dust off my old team jacket and wear it somewhere or another, I’m sure…)

And over on My London Your London I’ve an account of a visit to the Renaissance Faces exhibition at the National Gallery – for a different view I decided to go around just looking at the women (well, OK, I did peek at the men too, but I concentrated on the women.)

Politics

Pleasant, atheist societies

An interesting exploration of why more atheist societies are more decent than religious ones, and why claims that religious people are “more pleasant” fall apart on closer examination.

Which ties rather in with a piece about the role of the Mormon church in the passing of the ban on same-sex marriage in California. Apparently the proposition was pushed through with support from “Catholics, evangelical Christians, conservative black and Latino pastors, and myriad smaller ethnic groups with strong religious ties”, as well as the Mormons – now that is what you call an unholy coalition.

London

How to solve a problem of some leaflets

Handy tip: If you have multiple boxes of leaflets to shift across London (a lot more than will fit on a bicycle), ring up Addison Lee.

I called this morning at 8, they did the pickup at 9 and I had them at 10 – all for £20. The alternative would have been faffing around with minicabs or getting a car club car and getting hopelessly lost in central London – it was good value. And you don’t need an account – which is usually what stymies such arrangements.

(And no, I don’t own any shares in the company.)

Miscellaneous

From the inbox

Good news from Scotland, where the scheme pioneered by Greens in Kirklees, to provide free insulation to every whose house needs it, has won the backing of MSPs – proposed by the Greens and backed by the SNP and Labour.

On a far smaller scale, but still worth plugging, on the model of freecycle in Camden a plant exchange – designed for all garden things, has begun. (Would have come in handy when I moved and had to dump compost worms in the garden, even though I knew they probably wouldn’t do terribly well.)

And worth plugging, a survivor’s account of domestic violence sets out its corrosive framework.

Books Women's history

Women of the Revolution

When it comes to most of the major events of history, you have to go looking for the women, have to hunt in the darker corners of the archives, seek their behind-the-scenes presence. That's not, however, the case with the French Revolution. From the legendary revolutionaries Theroigne de Mericourt and Olympe de Gouges, who had hoped that the new regime would extend some of the rights now being given to men to their wives and sisters, to the tricoteuse watching heads roll from the guillotine, women's role was very public, if very controversial, and anyone who's studied the Revolution at even the most basic level will have some sense of it.

But there's far, far more to know – and for an overview you couldn't do any better than Marilyn Yalom's Blood Sisters: Women of the French Revolution. She's collected all of the revolutionary memoirs of women known, and sorted and sifted them into one neat, accessible volume. Yalom provides a certain amount of academic framing for this, noting particularly the way in which women jump from the personal to political and back again, giving equal importance to each, while also often putting themselves into the background and their male relatives (whose defence is often the putative aim of making a record). But mostly she simply lets the women tell their stories, while providing enough context to explain and amplify them.

The aristocratic women are here. There's the Duchesse de Tourzel, the famously level-headed and sober figure from the mad court of Versailles who was on the fateful flight to Varennes that sealed the fate of the royal family. She was an acute observer; as Yalom records, she noted that as the family was returned to Paris: "Following the order of Monsieur de La Fayette, everyone had his head covered, he had also enjoined them to remain absolutely silent to show the King, he said, the feelings his trip had inspired. His orders were so strictly observed that several scullery-boys without hats covered thei heads with their dirty, filthy handkerchiefs.

And almost at the other end of the social scale, yet servant too at the very end to Marie-Antoinette was Rosalie Lamorliere, a humble servant who told her story to one of the queen's early biographers. Yalom notes that here is a simple but seemingly honet witness who "spares us nothing — neither the queen's last bowl of soup not the vaginal hemorrhaging to which she was subject".

So too are the Revolutionaries– Madame Roland, who in the five months in prison before her execution wrote, Yalom says, "the work that would become the most famous eyewitness chronicle of the Revolution", to Charlotte Robespierre, who late in life wrote a hagiographic memoir attempting to exonerate and explain her brother.

But as so often it is the humbler stories that are really gripping. I found most powerful, and astonishing here that of Renee Bordereau, whose life was preserved in a "47-page poorly printed pamphlet" (which might so easily have been entirely lost). As Yalom says, in translation, where the French genderised language is lost, you might think this was a male tale:

Arriving near the Loire, I destroyed five of my enemies, and finishing off the day, I broke my sword on the head of the last one… Seeing only one horseman near me, I doubled back to our army. I alone, killed twenty-one that day. I'm not the one who counted them, but those who followed me, and if they hadn't said so, I wouldn't have spoken about it myself.

It sounds like grandiose boasting, yet Yalom reports there are multiple corroborations of the tale, including in two of the other accounts that she records of the extremely vicious "Vendee Insurrection" (which occurred when this isolated, traditional region refused to accept Revolutionary rule).

And this was not some hardened to insensitivity soldier: Bordereau reports the killing of four republicans one day after seeing "one of them had a child of about six months stick on his bayonet with two chickens." An image that she later repeats as obviously haunting her. She survived the war, Yalom tells us, was imprisoned by Napoleon for six years, and did not gain her liberty until the return of Louis XVIII in 1814, when she was also granted money.

It's a story that begs for a grander telling, a complete book, for Yalom has space for little more than a taster. But for an overview for women in the Revolution, this is a great start – a guide to further reading. And if you want to feel like you've got a decent historic grasp of the Revolution, you certainly can't leave out women's place in it.