Category Archives: Politics

Environmental politics

GDP as ‘fairytale’

To a new book club last night, where the topic of discussion was
Capitalism: As If the World Matters, by Jonathon Porritt.

It is an attempt, we concluded, to reframe “green” thought going back to the seventies into a form and vocabulary with which economists and businesspeople might be comfortable.

In the discussion I managed to make some economists very uncomfortable (sorry!) by suggesting that GDP was a “fiction”, which another commentator later modified to “fairytale”. That might sound a bit extreme, but the point I was making is that it has as a measure no absolute value – it is just a collection of figures that everyone has agreed means something. (A bit like money.) Of course the obvious feminist example of this is that it doesn’t count unpaid (but clearly valuable) outputs of labour such as caring and housework.

We were discussing the difficulties of creating/agreeing a “green GDP measure”. My view on this is select a few sensible figures, produce a formula to plug them into and push it hard; don’t try to get a “perfect”, exactly balanced measure, because such a thing doesn’t exist.

Feminism

Interesting women

Senait Mehari has gone from being a child soldier in Eritria enduring some of the worst conditions on earth to being a pop star in Germany.

As her book Heart of Fire graphically describes, Mehari lived in conditions so squalid that she was bitten by rats at night. She had to bury corpses and experience the deaths of other child soldiers.
“The only thing that makes me happy is that I never killed anyone myself. The knowledge of that would kill me,” she says. “I went to the front to fight, but I used to wee in my underwear from fear. The soldiers all teased me about it. They made up a name for me, and used to sing it at me.
“They didn’t want innocence. We were never cuddled. We were drilled to kill; we were all fighting for independence from Ethiopia. The war had a reason; but using children?”

By contrast, The Countess of Mar has a title going back to 1115, an aristocratic hateur and an independent mind, having just resigned in protest from the Immigration Appeal Tribunal.

“I think it is accepted among peers that some have bought their peerages,” she says casually, “although that has probably always been the case. Where it has gone to the dogs in the last 10 years is we have got a lot of people who have lost an election (to the Commons). Why should we get the dross?” If you think that spirited, wait for her view of the appeal tribunal. “I don’t tolerate fools gladly,” she says, appraising me over the floral teacups. “I just grew irritated. The management of the tribunal got so bad. It is an appalling con. My conscience could no longer stand it.” Relations with Hodge nosedived last Christmas. “I had a huge stand-up row with him,” she says.

Politics

A measure of public opinion about America

This has had little publicity, but is an interesting of how America has come to be viewed in the world:

Five Christian peace activists have been declared not guilty of criminal damage after they disabled a US warplane on its way to Iraq.
The jury of five men and seven women took four and a half hours to reach its unanimous decision.
It was the third attempt at trying the five who pleaded not guilty to two counts each of causing damage without lawful excuse to a naval plane, property of the United States government and to glass door panels, property of Aer Rianta at Shannon Airport, Clare on February 3, 2003….
The accused at all stages accepted that they had gone into a Shannon Airport hangar with hammers and damaged the aircraft. They argued that they had a lawful excuse for doing so as they believed they were acting to protect lives and property in Iraq.

The jury system can be a very powerful tool for the public to send messages to the politicians. Whether of course they are prepared to listen is another question.

Feminism

The next step for 60s feminists

A feminist nursing home – or rather to put it more subtly, a co-operative for old women. The driving force is “Mme Clerc, a mother of four who turned from a “bourgeois, Catholic housewife” into a militant feminist with her own business after her divorce in 1968.”

“We’re going to take all the decisions. We want to change the way society looks at old people, the way old people look at society and the way old people look at themselves,” she said.
“There will be 17 million people over the age of 65 in France by 2010 and we need to take charge of our own lives.”
The home will function without care assistants or resident doctors.
There will be no men except, perhaps, for occasional high-jinks. “A party now and again cannot do any harm,” Mme Clerc said. She launched the idea in 1997 after the difficult experience of looking after her elderly mother.

Sounds like a great idea to me.

Feminism

Today’s must-read

An account of the making of a television programme about the execution of a 16-year-old girl in Iran for a “crime against chastity”.

The programme is on BBC2 tonight for those for whom it is relevant.

Feminism

Campaigning for ‘Wayne Rooney’s sister’

Over on Comment is Free I’ve started up a bit of a storm with a post in favour of unisex sport. Just as once Virginia Woolf spoke about the lack of opportunities for “Shakespeare’s sister”, I want to campaign for “Wayne Rooney’s sister”.