Category Archives: Politics

Environmental politics

Pick that nursing home carefully

There are a lot of “cor isn’t it hot, here’s how to cool down” stories around in the UK media at the moment repeating the same statements of the bleeding obvious, as we’re well into a second week of 30-plus temperatures (in London at least). But the Guardian has an interesting, thoughtful piece today combining global warming reflections with practical advice – it has me looking now at my balcony windows wondering if it would indeed be possible to fit externa shutters. (Interestingly this piece says that internal blinds are useless, since by then the heat is already in the room, which makes sense when you think about it.)

And it reports that even after the scandal of 2003, when 30,000 died across Europe, primarily in France, the deaths are starting again this year – usually oldies who are literally being broiled alive from within. (And it isn’t even August yet.) The fault lies in their environment, building design ill-adapted to the realities that we are fast moving towards every summer being a 2003, and ignorance among communities yet to make behavioural adaptations.

Feminism

A brave woman and an inventive lawyer

A fascinating case reported today in which a young Sikh woman whose life was made an absolute misery by her mother-in-law used legislation originally designed for stalkers to win £35,000 compensation.

“A devout Sikh who entered into the marriage willingly, Ms Singh said she had accepted she would live with her husband’s family – but her mother-in-law’s campaign of torment led to serious health problems and the breakdown of the marriage in March 2003.
She was forced to do menial housework for hours and was kept a virtual prisoner in the house, beginning her domestic duties at 6.30am. Ms Singh told the court her mother-in-law called her a “poodle” and contrived a work routine – including cleaning toilets without a brush – designed to “exhaust and humiliate” her.
Ms Singh claimed that she was not allowed to visit the local Sikh temple, and was allowed only four short visits home to her parents in the weeks after her wedding. She said her telephone use was limited and her calls monitored.
The court also heard that Mrs Bhakar forced her daughter-in-law to have her hair cut to shoulder length, despite knowing her religious beliefs forbade it.”

The mother-in-law in the case had lived in Britain for decades, so while there is undoubtedly a clash of cultures here, as an abuser she can have had no excuse of lack of knowledge of British laws and norms.

Politics

The criminal misunderstanding is fear of crime

Over on Comment is Free I’ve got a piece arguing that you are less likely to be a victim of violent crime in Britain today than at any time in history. There’ve been surprisingly few commenters disagreeing with me… but perhaps Guardian readers are better informed than most.

Feminism

Fear for the women of Afghanistan

With state of the whole country bring described by a British general as close to anarchy, there’s more bad news specifically for women:

AFGHANISTAN’S notorious Department for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice, which was set up by the Taliban to enforce bans on women doing anything from working to wearing nail varnish or laughing out loud, is to be re-created by the government in Kabul….
President Hamid Karzai’s cabinet has approved the proposal to re-establish the department, and the measure will go to Afghanistan’s parliament when it reconvenes later this summer. The conservative complexion of the assembly makes it likely to be passed.
“When we talk of ‘vice and virtue’ . . . the one introduced by the Taliban comes to our minds. But it won’t be like that,” insisted Mohammad Karim Rahimi, a spokesman for the president. …
Nematullah Shahrani, the religious affairs minister who will oversee the department, claims it will focus on alcohol, drugs, crime and corruption. But critics point out that Afghanistan’s criminal laws already address these issues and say that once the department has been re-established, it will be easy to misuse.

Feminism Science

Good news on the Pill

There’s still an awful lot of misinformation and unnecessary fear around about the contraceptive pill, as evidenced by a debate that I got into recently over on Blogcritics.

So a very interesting report in the Independent today:

The contraceptive pill saves the lives of up to 3,000 women a year in the UK and Europe, according to new medical research.
A number of studies now suggest that the Pill reduces the risk of ovarian cancer significantly. One study, reported in the British Journal of Cancer this week, found a protective effect of up to 50 per cent for Pill users, while another, reported in the European Journal of Cancer Prevention, found a similar effect after analysing data on the use of the Pill since its introduction.
According to the studies, women who use the contraceptive pill reduce their risk of developing ovarian cancer by more than a third, and the longer they take it for, the greater the protection …
…The report says women who used the Pill at some time are 30 per cent less likely to develop the cancer. The protection increases with the length of time a woman takes the Pill by around 5 per cent a year, to about 50 per cent protection for long-term use. The reduced risk was seen in women both with and without a family history or genetic predisposition to ovarian cancer.

Of course there are other potential problems – this is only focusing on one form of cancer, but I fear a lot of the knee-jerk “it must be bad for you” reaction has an underlying moral focus of – “it makes your life easier, frees you to sleep with whoever you want, so there must be a big negative in there”.

Feminism Science

The hysterectomy butchery goes on

For at least a century, women have been subjected to unnecessary hysterectomies – a serious, painful operation with broad effects. This now far less common than it used to be, but it seems about 5,900 unnecessary hysterectomies are still being done in the UK each year.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, there are more operations in poorer, socio-economically deprived areas of the country than in wealthier, more educated areas.

But wherever you are, there’s a strong cautionary note down the bottom of the story:

He said that a study in the United States had found that 55 per cent of care was appropriate to patients’ needs, adding that there was “no reason to suspect” the situation was different in England.

“Doctor knows best” the majority of the time, but it is only a very slim majority.