Category Archives: Politics

Books History Politics

Notes from Colonialism and Modern Social Theory by Gurminder K Bhambra and John Holmwood

P. 94 “The very spaces where Marx and Engels imagined the American cotton monopoly would be broken were those of empire … yet nothing in Marx’s immanent critique of Hegel and of his treatment of alienated labour foreclosed the inclusion of colonial forms of labour, of chattel slavery alongside wage slavery, of forced labour alongside free labour. The problem arose precisely because of what he uncritically accepted from Hegel and the wider tradition of European social theory, namely a stadial theory of society and of human ‘progress’. Marx was so keen to look forward beyond capitalism that he could not see the wider aspects of the past and present that structured future possibilities.”

P. 124 “the modern capitalism that Weber addressed was strongly associated with colonialism. This is true of internal colonialism, where the association was manifest in the reinforcement of Germany’s eastern borders through settlement and in the reinforcement of German identity against ethnic Poles and Jews; and it is also true of external colonialism, that is, German expansion into Africa and the Pacific region. The link with colonialism is further implicity in the very organisation of Weber’s Protestant Ethic study … the spirit of capitalism is associated with settler colonialism in the United States via the figure of Benjamin Franklin, the primary source of Weder’s delineation of the distinctiveness of the spirit of capitalism. It was predation, not piety, that was unleashed globally through what Lebovics calls ‘rapacious and rebellious men of wealth’” (“The Uses of America in Locke’s Second Treatise of Government’ Journal of the History of Ideas 47 (4) 567-81)

P. 129 “Weber understood the nation as a simple natural category – he gave no recognition to historical complexity or contemporary contradiction – and presented it as the fundamental value with which a German social science should operate – despite the call for social science to be value-free… The German empire may have lasted only 30 years, from 1884 to 1915, but imperialism was a constitutive aspect of the project of nation state formation, as identified by Weber himself. Nations, he argued, were not defined merely by ethnic or cultural homogeneity, but by the act of welding a community with shared political destinies and struggles for power… there is an obvious split between domestic populations, on behalf of which the claim for legitimacy is made, and overseas populations, who must accept their domination as ‘fact’. 

P. 193 “The significance of slavery for the social development of America, Du Bois argued, rested upon ‘the ultimate relation of slaves to democracy’. In his view, this relationship demonstrated the limits of democracy in the matter of determining who was to be free, who was to be schooled, and who had the right to vote – in other words, who was considered a full citizen. Citizenship was defined in terms of whether the worker – here the black worker – had control over his or her own labour. Du Bois connected the black worker in the United states under slavery with that ‘dark vast sea of human labor in China and India, the South Seas and all Africa; in the West Indies and Central America … that great majority of mankind on whose bent and broken backs rest today the founding stones of modern industry… according to Du Bois the social and political emancipation of the colonial working class would be a precondition for the general emancipation of labour, including in the United States. This was a global argument similar to the one about African American suffrage in the South, according to which it was the actions of emancipated African Americans that produced a general improvement for all, albeit one from which they were subsequently excluded.”

P. 200 Du Bois Wrote “that, when working people in European countries began to demand ‘costly social improvements from their governments’ the financial burdens were likely to be balanced through increased investment in (and extractivism from) the colonies. In this way “democracy in Europe and America will continue to impede and nullify democracy in Asia and Africa. The social and economic improvements that he argued were necessary to realise a proper emancipation of African Americans and of other colonised people came to be part of the postwar settlement for white majority populations in Europe and the United States. These improvements were paid for from a patrimony of enslavement and colonialism…. The problem of democracy, he state, was the poverty in which most people live: the poverty of the colonised, the poverty of the smaller nations, and also the poverty within the colonising countries.”

P. 209 We have not attempted to deny the importance of class, gender, or other divisions that have preoccupied European sociology over the decades since the Second World War. We have sought to show how bringing the colonial contact and the imperial realities of modernity into focus will produce a fundamental shift in our ways of understanding what falls under the jurisdiction of sociology. Our book has been influenced by calls to ‘decolonise’ the university, but what does that mean when colonialism has been so thoroughly effaced from the self–understanding of academia. For those who practice sociology in places that were under European colonial combination, what this means is relatively clear. It means addressing how their institutions were produced or reproduced as part of a colonial system and how structures and curricula were shaped y their particular location in that system. For sociologists who work in institutions of the former metropoles, the answer is less clear because the shaping of these institutions y colonialism is less obvious to them. … the issue is not simply to add colonialism to sociology’s repertoire of topics, but to show how that repertoire must change and how the concepts and methodologies with which it is associated must be transformed. What does it mean to ‘decolonise’ a curriculum in which colonialism is not recognised? Paradoxically if our book is to be understood as an attempt at ‘decolonisation’, it is one that has had to proceed by putting colonialism into the picture .. modern social theory begins by being saturated with the presence of colonialism and the interpretative issues it posed. How do we engage with others when their presence is an obstacle to our interests? How do we use others to further our own interests? These were unavoidable questions in the early modern period. As colonialism became institutionalised, these questions receded from the centre to the periphery. … European nations … included the United States … were engaged in colonial and imperial projects continuously throughout self-proclaimed modernity, and so their impacts could not be denied … we argue for a renewal of social theory and sociology … central … is to recognise and address five fictions that currently organise understandings…

Fiction 1 : The idea of stages of society

The first fiction is associated with the idea of a ‘state of nature’ … against the ‘state of society’… fosters a concern to delineate the characteristics of modern society against which other societies can be described and classified. We regard the idea of modern society as equally fictional, because it carried the imprint of the original fiction. Once stages of society are delineated, it becomes possible to arrange them hierarchically in conformity with ideas of development and progress and to associate particular kinds of social relationships with each type of society … colonialism and its practices of appropriation – of territories, of resources, and of people – have an explicitly but ambiguous place within these constructure… people are characterized as being at a lower stage of development and an entire vocabulary of ‘savagery’ and ‘barbarity’ is applied to them, notwithstanding the brutality of those who describe themselves as ‘civilized’. We need to move away from the idea of types of society that can be investigated separately from the relationships between them. We must instead understand how those connections structure ideas of difference and domination.

Fiction2 Liberty, autonomy and modern subjectivity 

“Modern society is assumed to inaugurate a distinctive kind of subjectivity, associated with the modern individual and his or her self-determining capacity to act on the basis of reason and self-interest. This is the individual ‘capable of property’ in contrast to individuals who are either incapable of or indifferent to property. … this kind of individualism is represented as having developed within a religious tradition … but it is also a development that leaves religion behind. In the tradition of modern social theory, especially that associated with Kant and Hegel, modern reason is about developing autonomy and freedom and subjecting institutions such as those of religion to a criticism led by reason. … When critical theory regards private property as a limit on self- emancipation, it does so after having postulated that the development of private property was itself a necessary stage in the process that leads to its transcendence. The very idea of an ‘unfinished’ project of modernity presupposes that modernity is a civilizing project and that we should look at all premodern societies as inferior precursors, beset by traditional authority and inadequate selves, and not as bases of knowledge and sources of experience from which we can also learn.

Fiction 3 The idea of the nation state

“In the realisation of rights, contingencies of exclusion can be overcome through a process of recognition of their false limitation (ie false from the perspective of a proper understanding of their underlying nature). This is a standard interpretation of the extension of political rights from properties males to all males, then from men to women, and so on. However, in the case of issues of race and ethnicity, inequalities are constructed both inside and outside the newly established boundaries of the nation. From the outside, subjects of empire are denied inclusion among beneficiaries when the patrimony of empire is distributed; from the inside, they are denied full citizenship in the newl understood nation. As a result, people who in reality share the common political heritage of empire and now represented as ‘immigrants within its metropoles and are seen as threats to the nation’s solidarity and social contract.

Fiction 4: Class and formally free labour

“The class division that Marx described depends on the centrality of formally free labour and on the commodification of labour power in capitalist modernity. We have argued that these two features are called into question once we understand the colonial (and imperial) nature of modernity. Commodified labour power does not develop as the central form of capitalism; moreverm capitalist nation states are able to divide their populations between national citizens and colonial subjects. As Du Bois noted, this opens possibilities for a ‘decommodification’ of labour power within the metropole by using colonial patrimonies in the provision of strtuified and other collective goods. At the same time, colonial subjects are denied the status of free labour and subordinated to various forms of indenture… in the metropole indenture retyurns in the form of treating migrant labour as not worthy of the rights and rewards associated with the citizenship status afforded to nationals.

Fiction 5: the fiction of sociological reasoning.

“Methodological claims that are made in this discipline. They all tend to present sociological reasoning as ahistorical and as a necessary condition for an objective inquiry. In this way sociological reasoning is assimilated to the general claim of the Enlightenment, and sociology aligns itself with a critical project that continues that claim… we do not argue for some form of relativism or for multiple perspectives …. We argue for a transformation of our own perspective as a result of learning from others. The first step in any process of learning is the recognition of a limitation in one’s understanding. We have shown that colonialism has structured European modernity as well as European thought, hence recognising its significance opens an opportunity to practice sociology differently.

Books Politics

The Metaverse: And How It Will Revolutionise Everything

A title with which I profoundly disagree, but useful to see what claims being made. And no, there is no reference to the environment.

p. 10 For all the success of Second Life, it was the rise of virtual world platforms Minecraft and Roblox that brought its ideas to a mainstream audience in the 2010s. In addition to offering significant technical enhancements compared to their predecessors, Minecraft and Roblox also focused on children and teenage users, and were therefor far easier to use…By the end of 2021, more than 150 million people were using Minecraft every month – more than six times as many as in 2014, when Microsoft bought the platform. Despite this, Minecraft was far from the size of the new market leader, Roblox, which had grown from fewer than 5 million to 225 monthly users over that same period. According to Roblox Corporation, 75% of children ages 9 to 12 in the United States regularly used the platform in Q2 2020. Combined, the two titles amassed more than 6 billion hours of monthly usage each, which spanned more than 100 million different in-game worlds and had been designed by over 15 million users. The Roblox game with the most lifetime plays – Adopt Me! – was created by two hobbyist platers in 2017 and enabled users to hatch, raise and trade various pets. By the end of 2021, Adopt Me’s virtual world had been visited more than 30 billion times  – more than 15 times the average numbers of global tourism visits in 2019.

P 17 The very idea of the Metaverse means an ever-growing share of our lives, labor, leisure, time, wealth, happiness and relationships will be spent inside virtual worlds, rather than just extendedor aided through digital devices and software. It will be a parallel plane of existence for millions, if not billions, of people, that sits atop out digital and physical economies, and unites both. As a result, the companies that control these virtual worlds and their virtual atoms will likely be more dominant than those who lead in today’s digital economy.”

p. 39 Almost all the most popular virtual worlds today use their own different rendering engines (many publishers operate several across their titles), save their objects, textures and player data in entirely different file formats and with only the information that they expect to need, and have no systems through which to even try to share data to other virtual worlds.  As a result, existing virtual worlds have no clear way to find and recognise one another, nor do they have a common language in which they can communicate, let alone coherently, securely and comprehensively.”

p. 48 We don’t want virtual worlds in the Metaverse to merely persist or respond to us in real time. We also want them to be shared experiences. For this to work, every participant in a virtual world must have an internet connection capable of transmitting large volumes of data in a given time (high bandwidth), as well as low latency (fast) and continuous (sustained and uninterrupted) connection toa a virtual world’s server (both to and from)… perhaps the greatest constraint facing the Metaverse today – and the one that is hardest to solve. Simply put, the internet was not designed for synchronous shared experiences. It was designed, instead, to allow for the sharing of static copies of messages and files from one party to another.”

p. 53 “there are no simple, inexpensive or quick solutions. We will need new cabling infrastructure, wireless standards, hardware equipment, and potentially even overhauls to foundational elements of the Internet Protocol Suite, such as the Border Gateway Protocol.”

p. 55 Even nonpersistent virtual worlds that are less than 10 square kilometres in surface area, severely constrained functionally, operated by the most successful video game companies in history, and running on even more powerful computing devices still struggle to sustain more than 50 to 150 users in a shared stimulation.. Fortnite’s famous 2020 concert with Travis Scott. “players” converged on a much smaller portion of the map, meaning the average device had to render and compute far more information. Accrdoingly, the title’s standard cap of 100 players per instance was halved, while many items and actions, such as building, are disabled, thereby reducing the workload. While Epic Games can rightly say more than 12.5 million people attended this live concert, those attendees were split across 250,000 separate copies (meaning they watched 250,000 versions of Scott) of the event that didn’t even start at the same time.”

p. 75 Most online games try to send as much information as possible to the users in advance, and as little as possible when they are playing… files are so large because they contain nearly the entire game, namely its code, game logic and all the assets and textures required for the ingame environment (every type of tree, every avatar, every boss battle, ever weapon)”

Books Environmental politics Science

Notes from Endless Forms: The Secret World of Wasps

p. 31 Current estimates put insects at around 479 million years old, making them the oldest land animals. One hundred and 30 million years later, homometabolous insects appeared: these are the insects that separate youth from adulthood with metamorphosis… When the first hymenoptera came along a mere 280 million years ago, it was a wasp. The prototype wasp was a vegetarian, and a rather inelegant-looking like creature without a sting. We know this because this is what its ancesteors – the sawflies – are like… also known as wood wasps or horntails… the name refers to the sawfly’s lack of the wasp waist. They also lack the agile flight and hard-cuticle armour of their more waspish relatives… the broad-bellied maiden aunts of the wasp world: stumpy, fierce and functional, they trail a clunky ovipositor on their rear, corrugated like a saw to cut into the plants in which they lay their eggs.”

p. 42 There are about as many fossil ants as there are fossil dinosaurs: over 750 described species of preserved anys have been found from at least 70 locations across the planet… in the Cretaceous period, a huge diversity of crazy-looking ants evolved, and scientists have had a lot of fun naming them. Take the ‘hell ant’, for example, with scythe-like mandibles that jutted menacingly upwards from the jawline… There are also the ‘iron-maiden’ ants, with ferocious mouth pasts covered in spikes designed to immobile prey. And the ‘beast ants,’ so called because of their colossal forelimbs, enormous alien eyes and many-tooth mandibles that swivelled open to receive what must have been very large prey… all went extinct in the late Cretaceous mass=extinction event, over 50 million years ago.”

p. 43 What makes an any an ant, and not a wingless wasp… Ants are the only stinging Hymenoptera that have a metapleural gland, a slit- of pustule-like opening found on the back of the thorax in workers and queens. This is a rather clever invention as it exudes a range of antibiotics, which help combat diseases in the colony. It also produces chemicals used in communication. Ants also have ‘elbowed’ antennae (‘geniculated’ if you’re an any taxonomist), made possible thanks to an extra-long first antennal segment. Another any giveaway is that the second abdominal segment in node-like, being constricted at front and back; in wasps, this segment is just a smooth and simple waist.”

p. 44 “The bee fossil record remains scrappy and sparse compared to that of ants. Most of the bee fossils are solitary species, while most of the fossil specimens are social bee workers from species that lived in damp forests and fed on resins. Since social bees didn’t evolve until 60 million years after the first solitary bees, the vast majority of bee fossils are not especially useful for revealing how wasps became bees. Despite this, we have two fossilised contenders for the star role as wasp-bee – they come from  Burmese amber that formed in tropical forests 100 million years ago. Fossils of Melittosphex burmensis and Discoscapa apicula … are so different from each other that they delong to different biological families … there are no living representatives of their families.”

“Another candidare for the closest living relatives to bees are the Ammoplanidae, tiny wasps barely 2-4 mm in length… the wasp-bee fossils that have been found are also extremely small. Since the flowers of the early Cretaceous would have been very small, it would make sense if the first bees were sized to fit. Intriguingly, Ammoplanidae hunt tiny pollen-eating insects called thrips.”

p. 63 “bradykinins are the key neurotoxin component of wasp venom. They give the hunter the power to ensure that its prey victim is properly paralysed.,,, Ants also have ‘wasp kinins’. Bees, however, appear to have lost them. .. Intriguingly though, not all wasps have these magic peptides. Apoid wasps, Eumeninae (such as potter wasps) and Pompilidae (the spider hunters) all appear to lack bradykinins in their venom, but they still manage to paralyse their prey effectively. The jury is out on which ingredients they use. … The ‘mammoth wasp’ is a European species… the largest wasp in Europe… Stocky, with large abdomens… these colids spend their time digging around in the dirt, looking for scarab beetle larvae… series of landmark papers used cockroaches to show that wasp kinins can irreversibly block synaptic transmission across nerve cells. … the neurone pathways that are disrupted by bradykinins are the same as those targeted by the group of widely used pesticides (known as neonicotinoids) that have contributed to the declining populations of pollinating insects around the world. There is now overwhelming evidence that  these pesticides have a detrimental effect on the cognitive functioning of insects… It seems that the pharmaceutical industry has been mimicking the pharmacological secrets of solitary wasp venom without even realising it.”

p. 72 “We tend to forget that the antibiotic products of microbes and fungi are a natural phenomena: organisms produce them, along with other useful bioactive agents like anti-fungals, anti-virals and immunosuppressants, to combat other microorganisms they come into contact with…Beewolves have made a surprising contribution to our understanding of this are. The mother wasps inject their swaddled babes with antibiotics from their antennae. Beewolf mums are nosts to Streptomyces bacteria.. a species of Streptyomyces produces the antibiotic Streptomycin, the second most medically useful antibiotic to be discovered after penicillin, in 1942. Today 80% of medicinal antibiotics are sourced from Streptomyces… mother excretes Streptomyces bacteria from gland openings between her antennal segments and deposits it as whitish masses onto the walls of the baby’s cocoon… these helpful bacteria kill any fungi inside the cocoon… the wasp larva spreads the bacteria around its nursery, like an diligent toddler. If the larva happsn to be female, it adopts these bacteria as a lifelong companion .. she is equipped to keep her own offspring fungi-free. This clever evolutionary mechanism (known as vertical transmission) ensures that the bacteria stays closely hooked up with its host across generations. Its worked like this for 68 million years.”

p. 86 Plant volatiles produced in response to herbivory are widely used to draw in natural enemies, like wasps, flies and beetles, to rid the plant of its own predator… Few organisms can help their poos being a little smelly; it’s the nature of host products.. a form of chemical eavesdropping and one that parasitoids have become well known for.” Frass- term for insect excreta. “There is even a technical term for a chemical that is emitted by one organism and detected by another species which then benefit from it – this is called a kairomone.

p. 87 The olfactory skills of wasps have made them patentable property, thanks to the creation of the ‘Wasp Hound’, a handheld odour detector that uses the sensory powers of parasitoid wasps to indicate the presence of explosive materials like TNT, or illicit substances like cocaine. The work enghines are the tiny parasitoid wasps Microplitis croceipes, which respond to chemical cues in the frass of their host, the moth Heliothis zea, in order to local it. In the 1980s, scientists discovered that the females of this wasp could be taught to associate a specific type of molecule with a reqard through associative learning and so could be trained to detect very specific odours, even very closely related chemicals.”

p. 100 Spiders parasitised by Homonotus wasps soon recover their faculties and go about their business, oblivious to the fact they now have a wasp egg attached to their abdomen… even when that egg hatches and the wasp larva begins to chomp its way through the less essential body parts, ensuring that the spiders vital organs remain intact until the larva is ready to pupate. … she appears to only select gravid female spiders to parasitise. She positions her egg in exactly the right place so that the hatching baby wasp larva can dive straight into the spider abdomen and feast deliciously on the developing spider eggs. Pompilus is even cleverer, as she also manipulates the weaving skills of the spider to provide safety for her offspring. The spider spends her days in the terminal cell of her burrow, ever decreasing in form thanks to the fattening wasp larva. But during this time she inadvertently spins a protective envelope among the sand, making the burrow a safe haven for wasp pupation.”

p. 110 “Together the social insects account for about 75% of the world’s insect biomass. But wasps tell the story of sociality better than do ants and bees. There are no solitary ants and all ant species are superorganisms; they’ve left nothing in their evolutionary wake to tell us how they got there.  Honeybees, bumblebees and stingless bees are socially diverse and exciting, however, bees are just wasps that forgot how to hunt.”

p. 123 joneybees “Young bees start off their working life as nurses. As they get older, they graduate to out of hive work as foragers. Age is a steadfast regulator of behaviour in many social insects, not just honeybees, so much so that the process has its own name ‘age polyethism’. Does it also remind you of our solitary wasp, with her clock-like nesting cycle? Build, lay, provision, repeat. Chronology determins when she behaves in a particular way… honeybee cycle can be accelerated if a sudden demand arises for more foragers and fewer nurses and no matter how old they are, foragers can retreat to in-hive jobs should they be needed. .. some foraging honeybees specialise as nectar-foragers, while others are pollen-collectors… what they do, when and why is determined by a co-regulated set of four connected traits that all matter: ovaries, forage type, sugar cravings and age.. solitary reproductive insects forage on pollen and feed it to their brood, while they forage on nectar for personal delectation… this suite of linked behavious appears to respond to the instructions of a master regulator gene .. Vitellogenin is a precursor to egg yolk, and fundamental for reproduction in all egg-making animals…acts within a whole network of genes, producing molecules like hormones that carry instructions for the endocrine system.”

p. 128 Potter wasps perform some insect chemical wizardry while coiling the pots, enriching their walls with essential minerals such as magnesium, zinc and iron. Undoubtedly these garnishes contribute antibiotic properties to the nests, ensuring the brood is kept free of disease while it completes its lonely childhood, sealed in a pot… people in remote tropical parts of the world rely on these nests to distill essential minerals.. geophagy … eating insect-transformed earths is a traditional practice in parts of Africa, Asia and South America… provides women and children with the very same mineral supplements that you might buy in your local pharmacy… if an appropriately aged woman starts scratching the earth in search of a termite mound or wasp nest, it is taken as evidence that she is pregnant. These women have described how they ‘felt need’ or ‘strong desire’ to each insect earths.”

p. 164 “In some American populations of Poistes, wasps do seem to be able to recognise individuals by their facial markings, and they can learn new facial patterns… only insects known … not even honeybees can learn to recognise fellow bee faces. … not that useful for a honeybee, as every worker is (largely) equal. For a small foundress group of Polistes females .. crucial to the establishment and maintenance of the social hierarchy … the reproductive (dominant) foundress at the top and her subordinates forming an orderly queue below her… a few judiciously applied splashes of yellow face paint could upset the social pecking order… after an hour or so, however, social order would be re-established, suggesting that the wasps had learned the new look of their nestmates.”

p. 246 Bees distinguish between the concept of ‘same as’ and ‘different from’ in unconnected and contrasting objects… if it had learned that colour-matching produced a positive reward (such as sugar) … also vertical over horizontal lines… using a similar approach, bees could be trained to follow a ‘difference’ rule, if they say tallow at the entance, they didn’t choose a yellow branch. .. even more amazing… these visual cues could be replaced with odours and the bees were able to apply the sameness or difference rules they had learned …. Bees can transfer their abstract relational learning to different visual and olfactory cues. .. they can tell whether there is ‘more or less’ of something, and whether something is above or below another thing. He’s shown that bees count, and that they also have a concept of what zero means. Can be trained to respond additively – if trained that blue is good and yellow is good, when presented with blue and tallow they respond with twice the enthusiasm … known as configural learning.”

p. 249 Bees are reasoning, numerate, perceptive, complex cognitive organisms just like us. Despite their small brains and limited number of neurones, they have conceptual cognition. Just like you, they can link past experiences together for a future interaction with the world. This body of work has made scientists question what the minimal neural circuitry is for ‘higher-level’ cognitive function.”

-. 277 Biological control (or biocontrol) is a method of pest eradication that exploits pre-existing predator-prey relationships. It is a key ecosystem service, alongside pollination, and has an estimated value of well over $400 billion a year. In the US alone, the value of natural biocontrol provided by insects annually is estimated to be $4.5 billion…. Parasitoid wasps… account for almost 50% of the 230 invertenbrate species that are commercially used as biocontrol agents. For the price of a good bottle of wine, you can be the proud owner of enough Trichogramma wasps to strip your house clean of clothes moth eggs. Let them run free- don’t worry you won’t even see them, their wing span is about 0.5 mm 0 and within a few weeks, you’ll be moth- and wasp= free. The wasps lay their eggs inside moth eggs, which then hatch and feed off the moth egg, killing it. The wasps can’t survive without the moths.”

p. 278 Mealybugs adore cassava. In their homeland, the mealybug populations are kept at bay by the 1mm-long parasitoid wasp Anagyrus lopezi, which lays its eggs in mealybugs and nothing else. When cassava was first introduced to Africa and Asia to help feed hungry humans, everything went swimmingly,… until the mealybug arrived, causing 60-80 per cent reduction in crop yields… only saved by the rapid introduction of A. lopezi”.

p. 274 88% of flowering plants are pollinated by insects… thought to be worth more than $250 billion a year worldwide, contributing to almost 10% of the value of the world’s agricultural production . These figures are based on contributions to farmed crops and so overlook the value of pollination and predation that these insects perform in natural ecosystems.”

p. 279 The use of solitary hunting wasps for biocontrol in non-native regions has not been very successful. This is probably due to a poor understanding of their life histories and behaviour … when they are introduced to a new environment they often shift their prey preference… the best approach seems to be to adopt a local, native species.”

p. 290 The first Vespula vulgaris was spotted in New Zeland in 1921 but it wasn’t until the late 1970s that populations became properly established. Within 30 years, these invaders had completely altered the ecological balance of one of New Zealand’s most precious native habitats, the beech forests. The sooty beech scale insect is a true bug – a hermipteran … excrete a sugar rich honeydew from their behind which attracts an eclectic mix of invertebrates and vertebrates who feast on the sugary droplets; in return, they defend the sugar bug from predators… sugar actually comes from the plant, the bug plunges its mouth parts into the tree, tapping into the sugar-rich plant juices… being very long, the anus serves to keep the sugar hunters a safe distance away from the actual insect.. any honeydew that isn’t slurped up drops onto the bark, providing the perfect breeding ground for the black sooty fungus …. Beetles and moths feast on the fungus and its own secret microbiome of microorganisms. Along come the birds and lizards, many of which are found only in these beech forests, who munch on the moths and the beetles. Then along came the alien Vespula – she feasts like a hungry teenager at a sushi bar who knows they’re no picking up the bill, slurps up the honeydew but also picks off the protein feasts.”

p. 300 Over the course of the colony cycle in the UK, nests of the common yellowjacket produce an average of 9,600 adult wasps… total estimated pest biomass needed is 6.5 kilograms, which comes in at just shy of 130,000 insects per colony… Vespula wasps are likely to be removing over 30,000 arthropods per hectare and up to 234,000 per hectare in a good wasp year. .. unfussy opportunistic predators who are likely to be creaming off the most abundant invertebrates they encounter. This makes them rather useful as general caretakers of ecosystems; they help keep a diverse community of arthropod populations in check without hunting any to the brink of local existence.”

p. 307 Per unit of consumable protein, insect farming is twice as efficient as rearing cheicken… for every gram of protein insect-farming uses 17 times less water than cattle, and give times less than pig or chicken farming. At least 2 billion people across the globe consume insect protein as part of their diet. Over 2,000 insect species are eaten, with beetles (31.1%), butterflies and moths (17.5%) and wasps bees and ants (14.8%) being the most prominent. Wasps are usually eaten as larvae or pupae, and social species, like the Asian giant hornet, are especially popular because of the bonanza prize of thousands of brood from a single nest.”

Books Early modern history History Politics

Notes from Empires of the Weak: The Real Story of European Expansion and the Creation of the New World Order

P.11 MacDonald summarizes the dominant state of thinking in the discipline on why Europe conquered much of the rest of the world by exactly replicating the military revolution argument: “European warfare underwent a profound transformation beginning in the 16th century. On land, the spread of gunpowder-based weapons, as well as specialised fortifications designed to resist these arms, transformed the nature of combat. European armies were increasingly compelled to raise large standing armies, which were dominated by highly-trained and well-drilled infantry. Although driven by competition between European states, the unintended consqeuence of this ‘military revolution’ was to widen the gap in military power between Europe and the rest of the world.”

P. 20 “this process of discerning ‘what worked’ is by no means as easy as it sounds. Victory and loss in war are a result of complex and varying combinations of factors, many of the most important of which, like leadership and morale, are intangible. A study of contemporary military effectiveness  stresses indirect and hard to change factors like the international environment, political culture and social structure.”

P. 22 “In order for selection mechanisms to create a population of homogenous effective organisations … the ‘death rate’ amongst organisations has to be very high, the differences in effectiveness have to be large and consistent, and the environment has to stay fairly constant,,, these differences are difficult to meet in the context of military competition.”

P. 34 The way Westerners fought in the wider world in the early modern period was almost entirely different from the way they fought wars in Europe was almost entirely different from the way they fought wars in Europe with respect to nearly every one of the criteria that define the military revolution thesis. .. Rather than armies of 10s of thousands, the forces in Europe more commonly numbered only in the hundreds, While cannon-armed sailing ships were superior to anything other powers could put on the open ocean, they did not fundamentally change the balance of power.”

P. 36 Unless they enjoyed a major epidemiological advantage, Europeans were unable to defeat even middling non-Western powers in the period 1500-1750, and generally maintained their predominately nabal mercantile empires in the East under the sufferance of the Asian and African rulers o f the day. In the rare instance where Westerners sought to challenge this arrangement, they generally lost.”

P. 37 In Asia, great power armies that dwarfed their European counterparts hsd either already anticipated key elements of the military revolution centuries before Euopre, or had come up with alternatives.

P. 61 One of the few instances of the Portugese trying to conquer territory in Asia was their campaign against the rajah of Kandy in Ceylon. In 1594, 1630, and 1638 this resulted in disaster, as Portugese forces were ambushed and destroyed, their commaners being killed on each occasion… Kandyan forces did not have guns or armour like the Portugese, being armed with bows and spears, and thus they tended to avoid frontal attacks. Instead, they used the mountainous and forested terrain to wear down the Portugese with ambushes and attacks on their supply lines”

P. 74 There is no question that mainland Southeast Asian and perhaps most of the islands too had gubs well before the Europeans arrived. .. the sultan of Malacca was lentifully equipped with cannons by the time of the Portugese attack in 1511… diffusion of gunpowder weapons as beginning in Burma and Vietnam in the 1390s, before advancing to the rest of the region and Northern India through the next century, parallelling the fact that Mamluk and Ottoman guns had reached Western India by 500. Chinese cannons reached Java by 1421.”

P. 86 “the Mighals were not defeated by European,s and that though internal dynamics were the determining factor in their fall, their most dangerous military foes were Persians and Afghans, not the Portugese, Dutch or British.”

P. 87 “Bengal alone had a larger population than Britain in 1750.”

P. As in Africa, none of the Asian great powers had an interest in controlling sea routes or maritime trade in the way that Europeans obsessed about, making compromises and accommodations between the two groups much easier to strike.”

P. 100 “The repeated European disappointments and defeats at the hands of Islamic foes in North Africa right through to the 19th century scotches any notion that Western overseas expansion swept all before it. These reverses are even more significant given that the Spanish and Portugese committed far more resources in their failed expeditions across the Mediterranean than they ever did to those across the Atlantic or to the East. The Ottomans were dominant in Europe right through what is said to be the key century in the military revolution. The fact that their eclipse came only in the second half of the 18th century, and then at the hands of the Russians, is an awkward fit with the tenets of the conventional story. It is a strongly underappreciated fact that the Ottoman Empire enjoyed far more extensive and longer-lasting military and geo-political success than supposed paragons of modernity like the Dutch and the Swedes… Non-Western powers are portrayed as mere failures waiting to happen.”

P. 134 The Industrial Revolution was certainly a vital part of explaining how Europeans were able to build their new empires. But the prior question is why Europeans wanted to build huge empires. Given the at-best uncertain returns in military and economic terms, in many cases later imperial expansion seems to have reflected concerns about prestige and status in an international context where great power standing required colonies. In the decades after WWII, however, being in possession of colonies went from being valorized to being deeply stigmatised as part of a fundamental change in the mores of international society… the rise and fall of European empires were crucially driven and shaped by changes in ideas and cultural contexts, rather than just, or even mostly, material factors and rational means-end calculation.”

P. 134 “the functionalist model, premised on rational learning and Darwinian survival pressures, is implausiable. Against the expectation of convergence on a superior Western style of warfare, it is striking how often non-Western opponents have improved their performance by adopting a very different style of war.”

P. 143 Outside the settler countries of the Americas and Oceania, European dominance fell even more suddenly than it had been established. .. the declining legitimacy of empires reinforces earlier conclusions about the importance of culture and ideas, as distinct from rational pursuit of power and wealth, in the making and remaking of the modern international system. Second, the fact that ‘backward’ non-Western forces have repeatedly bested ‘advanced’ Western forces supports earlier skepticism about the significance of weapons and military technology in isolation from broader concerns.”

P. 144 The wars of decolonisation, and subsequent Western counterinsurgency campaigns, decisively undermines easy assumptions that victory goes to those with the most advanced technology, the largest economies, and the most developed state apparatus. .. Us and Western forces are perhaps even further away from solving these problems than they were 50 years earlier… Claims that these kinds of insurgencies are not ‘real’ major power wars completely fail to deal with the fact that this kind of expeditionary warfare was how Europeans built their empires and created the international system in the first place.”

P. 150 “Moving away from the conventional story of Western hegemony puts our current circumstances in a new light. A more cosmopolitan, less eurocentric perspective, giving due weight to regions beyond Europe, shows Western dominance of the international system as relatively fleeting, and thus makes it much less surprising if this dominance is now being challenged with the rise of powers beyond the West. A multipolar global international order becomes the historical norm rather than the exception. … The questions that we ask, and fail to ask, about history changes our views not only of where we have come from, but also where we are, and where we are going.”

Books Environmental politics History Politics

Notes from The World Turned Inside Out: Settler Colonialism as a Political Idea

P. 55 The Ulster Scots, or Scots-Irish, among other collectives, had turned the world inside out for decades… this group’s re-emigration is significant, because it confirms the choice to relocate as a political tradition. Between 1718 and 1775, more than 100,000 men and women migrated from Ulster to the North American colonies, in the largest such movement in the 18th century… Why did they leave the Old World. Many feared that a ‘counterrevolution’, a political upheavel that would undo the Glorious Revolution, was inevitable – they felt that their privilege as Protestants ion Ireland would be threatened… the expansion of linen manufacturing in Ireland had brought opportunity, but it also brough exposure to market downturns. Many Scots-Irish families had lost whatever security they once held, .. new labour practives were challenging the traditional roles of male householders… The Ulster Scots were not the poorest in Ulster, but they were under pressure during economic downturns. They felt that they could only retain their position by moving out… Bernard Bailyn has focused on the “distressed” Yorkshire “countryfolk” who faces “an uncertain economic future, many in a high state of religious agitation and eader to withdraw into a separate community of like-minded worshippers. Often affected by Methodist propaganda, they had a passionate desire to “draw apart from a corrupt and abusive world and to create a refuge for themselves and their community on the far margins of the British periphery. The promotional material for emigration to America insisted on the absence of feudal obligations… a desire to avoid landlords was more and more paralleled by a despire also to escape markets (a very demanding landlord indeed). On settler noted with pride that in America there “was no need for market days since each farm did its own slaughtering and raised most of what it consumed”.

P. 67 “as Cuba burned during the first war of independence, the colonial authorities were imagining a resettled order through displacement. An official scheme in 1871 proposed to import between 40,000 and 50,000 German immigrants to the island. Following a similar logic, and facing revolution during the second war of independence, they thought of displacing enture populations to strategic locations under a policy of ‘reconcentration’. These were the first concentration camps. But cramming the countryside with German settlers or emptying it entirely of unmanageable populations were two sides of the same coin. Displacement was still understood as an antidote to revolution.”

P. 70 “White in Britain Paine was a revolutionary, in America he was not. He chose America, arguing for its independence and for a repudiation of aristocratic and monarchic privileges … Radical egalisatrianims was his stance in one location but defence of property rights characterised his posture in another. Displacement had transformed his politics. Much later, in Agrarian Justice (1797), Paine suggested that 15 pounds be paid to every person on turning 21: a social entitlement that would have ensured the establisjhment of a yeoman republic of independent landowners. It was a proposal very similar to that found in Harrington’s Oceana, a proposal also evoked in Lane’s later “commonhold”.

P. 75 Wakefield believed that capitalism tended to produce the conditions for its own demise … Pauperisation was not the only problem: the sons of the lesser gentry were finding no career opportunities, and small capitalists were downwardly mobile – he would have known, as he was one of them. This was the social revolution that most concerned Wakefield, because, if the conditions of the labouring poor would necessarily deteriorate before they could improve, an imminent revolutionary crisis was inevitable. “A ruined man is a dangerous citizen,” Wakefield sourly noted, before adding “there are at all times in this country more people who have been ruined than in any other country.”

P. 88 Caroline Chishom’s activism for women’s emigration – she published tThe ABC of Colonisation in 1850 – also aimed to turn the world inside out. Chisholm consistently and influentially advocated for the sponsored emigration of “respectable” poor farmers and especially single women. The latter would enable colonial fathers of working-class families to become respectable manly breadwinners. Her insight was that it is appropriate reproduction that turns the world inside out and she called for the systematic “population” of Australia, which she saw as “the future England of our Southern Hemisphere”. 

P. 99 This synthesis had important gendered implications. Jefferson assumed that a farmer knew what was best for his fam, and that a father knew what was best for his family … Jeffersonianism represented the “apotheoiss of the republican father and head of the household”.

P. 106 “The Market Revolution was revolutionary indeed. Predicated on other revolutions – including the transport, legal and industrial revolutions – and on unprecedented economic development and a commercial boom, initially in wheat and cotton, it prompted many worlds turned inside out. Charles Sellers set the scene of ongoing culture wars between opposinig subcultures. “Arminiam” market contronted Aanitnomian” land … The market fostered individualism and competitive pursuit of wealth by open-ended production of commodity value that could be accumulated as money. But rural production of use values stopped once bodies were shelter and clothed and bellies provided for. Surplus produce had no abstract or money value and wealth could not be accumulated. Therefor the subsistence culture fosted family obligation, communal cooperation and reproduction over generations of a modest comfort”. 

“Banks, paper money and ‘money changers’ were all perceived as part of the market revolution from which the settlers were escaping in the first place.”

P. 298 “The political tradtions that aim to turn the world inside out constitute an anti-revolutionary sensibility that relies on three fantasies: perpetual household production, where capitalism never begins; perpetual primitive accumulation, where capitalism permanently remains in its initial stage, and where social contradictions are always deferred; and in the promise of political community somewhere else – the promise of a political community that is born without the need of violence or revolution. The first two fantasies are found to remain unfulfilled – contradictions are displaced too, sometimes quite rapidly. The spatial fix is at best a temporary solution. The first fantasy rests on a fundamental exclusion – a move that is inevitably and often spectacularly bio;lent. Setting up a polity against someone – in the case of settler colonialism, against indigenous peoples – is not like setting up a polity without them: the settler colonial polity cannot be amended by inclusion, because it is foundationally violent and dispossessory. If this exlusion is to be addressed, the settler colonial poultry must be dissolved, which is a … revolution. The world turned inside out cannot keep its promises.”

Books Politics

Notes from Debt and Austerity: Implications of the Financial Crisis, Jodi Gardner, ed

P. 3 “Financialisation, the increased importance of capital markets in turning the material economy into financial assets to be traded on global markets, is a key to understanding how debt circulates in global markets. The contemporary creation of new housing, urban infrastructure and student loans are all examples of how the material economy is as often as much about generating tradeable financial assets in global markets as responding to local demand. Scholars comment on the startling growth of traded assets in the run-up to the global financial crisis of 2008, and the importance of these flows to the UK and the US.”

P. 4 The speculative activity in financial markets was certainly not confined to housing. Consumer credit (eg car loans, credit card debt, student loans etc) grew rapidly in the decade before the global financial crisis, and was also converted into credit derivatives on global markets. Many argued that consumer debt replaced the state in stimulating demand, and fuelled the economic boom experienced before the financial crisis.”

P. 6 In response to the 2008 global financial crisis, the UK government, like those of many other countries, pursued emergency fiscal stimulus meqasures and bank bailouts to avert collapse of the financial system. Years of “quantative easing” followed through which central banks bought government bonds and corporate ‘toxic’ debt. In many ways the public safety net, which had been shrinking as a mechanism of popular redistribution, had not disappeared byuty was “placed under the banking sstem” in a fashion that was “unprecedented in scale and duration… private sector debt was transformed into a sovereign debt crisis in what Blyth called the “greatest bait and switch in modern history”… consensus around austerity was pushed by many national governments, such as in the UK, and by international institutions such as the European Commission, the IMF and the European Central Bank. These institutions saw sovereign debt as potentially economically and politically destablising and imposed austerity policies as a precondition for financial aid. Many academic and policy observers argued that austerity was more political than economic  that austerity was part of a longer-term political project to promote a permanent smaller state, a more reliberal state.”

P. 7 “Rarely did austerity policies remain at the central government level, but were often pushed down to the local level, where tough decisions about the distributional aspects of the cuts were forced onto local government… pushed the crisis to lower spatial scales of government, non-governmental actors and low-income households. Within the context of the UK and US, austerity was pushed down to the poorest areas in the country, which were dependent on redistributive grants from central government.”

P. 13 Citizens Advice highlights what they call “the hidden problem of household bill debt”. These debts are for essential services (including fuel, water, and telecoms, rent arrears, debts to government (such as council tax arrears or overpayments of tax credits) and fines or penalty notives. In 2017-18 Citizens Advice received almost 700,000 complaints about these debts – nearly double the complaints received about commercial consumer credit … the CAB estimates that in 2017 over £19 million was owed to government and essential services providers, a 34% increase from 2010.”

P. 18 “The growing use of surveillance and sanctions may be understood in relation to what Wacquant describes as the “distinctive paradox of neoliberal penalty”. That is, those governmental practices that celebrate the “free market” and individual responsibility, on the one hand, while deploying increasingly intrusive and punitive policies to protect the market, on the other.”

P. 23 “Smith examines Margaret Thatcher’s Right-to-buy policy as the key to understanding the “normalisation” of debt.” 

P. 25 “Although there are many forms of the poverty premium, we argue that the most important form of poverty premium is in the debt infrastructure itself – the numerous ways in which small debts, owed to the private or public sector, are allowed to escalate into large debts and into problem debt.